BecomingJulie
Bluelight Crew
An ideal language would have a perfect 1:1 mapping between concepts and words. It would be impossible to misunderstand (but also, there could be no poetry; not even a figure of speech). It would be possible to translate into any other language. It also couldn't possibly exist in reality (or at least, it would be a perpetual Work In Progress) -- but that does not diminish the usefulness of the abstract concept.
What we have in the real world is hundreds of different languages, that all set out originally to solve the same problem but took very different approaches. For every language, there is a subset that gives a very precise mode of speech, excluding all forms of literary device, that is an approximation of this ideal language and sufficient to describe, as completely as is known, at least the immediate environment of its users.
And culture doesn't have any intrinsic meaning. It's just the product of circumstances and people's perceptions thereof. People are all the same underneath, once you control for culture. The study of cultures can show how they were shaped by events, but I think you are ascribing too much significance to this. It's just stuff that happened; and if it had happened differently, we would have come out differently, but we would still be looking back just the same, trying to make sense of it.
What we have in the real world is hundreds of different languages, that all set out originally to solve the same problem but took very different approaches. For every language, there is a subset that gives a very precise mode of speech, excluding all forms of literary device, that is an approximation of this ideal language and sufficient to describe, as completely as is known, at least the immediate environment of its users.
And culture doesn't have any intrinsic meaning. It's just the product of circumstances and people's perceptions thereof. People are all the same underneath, once you control for culture. The study of cultures can show how they were shaped by events, but I think you are ascribing too much significance to this. It's just stuff that happened; and if it had happened differently, we would have come out differently, but we would still be looking back just the same, trying to make sense of it.