Well I never thought I would come -this- close to cheating on my SO on a Christmas day but sometimes life presents you with unexpected opportunities. Last Dec. 25, I hung out with an old friend of mine named Tamia. From the day we met I've always had a particular fondness for her. It's weird because I've always had a crush on her but I never did anything about it. I was OK with being her friend. Friendzoned they call it, but I didn't mind. I've always found her attractive, and I've told her that. But I've never asked her out in a dating sense. And she's never sent those female signals to show me she's interested in me. Last Dec. 25, 2015 Tamia and I had already been friends for seven years
. She's still hung over her ex who dumped her after a three-year relationship. Also, I'd already met a wonderful girl last February; with this other girl--let's call her Audrey--I was hit by a thunderbolt, I really fell for her. I was not too afraid to ask her out or anything because she's so beautiful and it just felt right. I always found it interesting that I could have lingering crush on Tamia but still fall hard and fast for Audrey, but as I said sometimes life presents us with unexpected opportunities.
Last Dec. 25, 2015 Tamia was really hurting from her break up and so she asked me to come drink and smoke with her in the evening. Prior to this my girlfriend Audrey had already been away for five months because she's been taking a PhD in another country. So I'd been getting more chances to hang out with Tamia. Because of her breakup, Tamia's been going on about how she'd be willing to just make out with random dudes if it "felt right" and it wasn't too pre-conceived--think of it as plausible deniability. So last Dec. 25, after we'd drunk and smoked a few, Tamia starts talking about how she needs somebody to make out with. Long story short, I would have absolutely done it, and she was practically already leaning into me, which is something she'd never done before. But all I could do was kind of glance at her a little and feel awkward hahahahahahaha. Anyway we moved on shortly after and nothing happened.
So now I feel this whole conflict of emotions and confusions. I love Audrey and I would not want to hurt her, so in that sense I "did the right thing." On the other hand I would be lying if I said I hadn't fantasized about making out with Tamia for so long already. And part of me feels like I missed that unexpected opportunity especially considering she was presenting herself to me in a way I never thought would be so straightforward (easy?). I'm not proud that I fantasize about Tamia and love Audrey. I did not do anything. but I feel like it was a missed opportunity. Does that make me an asshole? I want to do the right thing still. Would appreciate any feedback or advice especially from people who can understand where I'm coming from.

Last Dec. 25, 2015 Tamia was really hurting from her break up and so she asked me to come drink and smoke with her in the evening. Prior to this my girlfriend Audrey had already been away for five months because she's been taking a PhD in another country. So I'd been getting more chances to hang out with Tamia. Because of her breakup, Tamia's been going on about how she'd be willing to just make out with random dudes if it "felt right" and it wasn't too pre-conceived--think of it as plausible deniability. So last Dec. 25, after we'd drunk and smoked a few, Tamia starts talking about how she needs somebody to make out with. Long story short, I would have absolutely done it, and she was practically already leaning into me, which is something she'd never done before. But all I could do was kind of glance at her a little and feel awkward hahahahahahaha. Anyway we moved on shortly after and nothing happened.
So now I feel this whole conflict of emotions and confusions. I love Audrey and I would not want to hurt her, so in that sense I "did the right thing." On the other hand I would be lying if I said I hadn't fantasized about making out with Tamia for so long already. And part of me feels like I missed that unexpected opportunity especially considering she was presenting herself to me in a way I never thought would be so straightforward (easy?). I'm not proud that I fantasize about Tamia and love Audrey. I did not do anything. but I feel like it was a missed opportunity. Does that make me an asshole? I want to do the right thing still. Would appreciate any feedback or advice especially from people who can understand where I'm coming from.