Barbiturates are absolutely one of the worst class of drugs to take if your depressed at all.
Since "worse" is subjective, I won't attempt to prove you wrong, as matters of better or worse, good or bad, etc., are essentially matters of taste. Matters of taste cannot be proved factually or logically incorrect or invalid.
De gustibus non est disputandum , as the Romans said.
However, I've determined the most considerable and principal cause of my moderate depression to be my severe anxiety. I tend to worry myself into a depressive state. Therefore, it would seem appropriate to use an anxiolytic—barbiturates, say—to lessen the severity of the anxiety and, in turn, achieve a commensurate lessening in the severity of the depression.
They even make people with no mental health problems depressed sometimes especially if taken long term.
Taking any addicting substance long term is inadvisable. That's why I take barbiturates only as needed (when my anxiety is at its extremity and most insufferable), which is about once or twice per week on average. Taking them every day for a long-term interval is not only risky, but it is unnecessary.
So i would strongly suggest cutting them out. I have a friend who suffers from depression and was put on Phenobarbital by her doctor for some condition i forget and she went from being mildly depressed to suicidal depressed within about 2 days.
Her experience is obviously idiosyncratic. My experience with barbiturates, over a much lengthier period of use than 2 days (I've used them for years), has been the opposite.
People can have entirely different reactions to the same or similar drug and dose, which means extrapolating from the particular to the general is invalid and unjustifiable.
But one could take the aggregate of particular reactions to a specific drug and use it to develop a statistical conception of the typical reaction thereof, which can then be used as a meaningful and factual expectation of a drug's reaction in a randomly-chosen or hypothetical person.
This is not even mentioning that mixing Barbs with booze is a absolute fucking death wish. Scores of people died from this combo until just about every Barb besides Butalbital and Phenobarbital where removed from the market. Even today there are people who wind up as blue as a smurf from mixing Phenobarbital or Butalbital (the barb in Fiorinal/Fioricet) because it doesn't take that many tablets to kill you and you may forget you even took them thus you take more. But unlike when your suffering from a benzo and booze blackout where you often have a case of the disappearing benzos too many barbs on their own never mind with booze will kill you.
Unfortunately, it would not be in my best interest to give a sincere response to this segment of text. It seems any opinion expressed in a comment posted about barbiturates, that doesn't consist of incredibly embellished accusations of risk and danger or that fails to explicitly dissuade barbiturate use, would invariably be censored and the comment's poster forcefully slapped with an infraction.
Therefore, I shan't get too intertwined in this excursus, for fear I'd mention the unmentionable and be made to feel like I'm on an Internet message board version of the plot of Orwell's
1984 (again).