George.
I am quite calm.
So calm, I'm nearly dead.
I find this follow-up post of yours to be very well-written and honest.
Much more mature than some of the other debates I have taken part of.
Well done.
Simply leaving room to admit that it changed you is MORE than most MDMA users are capable of.
I agree with your statement that the 'core' remains intact, despite my alarming statements.
If I agree with this, then it must be true for most.
I should note that I know several BL members that would not make such a forgiving claim.
A minority of people do indeed change, like your LSD using friends, and struggle with intense anxiety and social dysfunction for YEARS. But in general, people do recover function.
I both agree and disagree with your claim that the brain is powerful enough to both create and overcome the anxiety caused by MDMA. Yes, there is a valid argument here and TOO many people on BL think it is the ONLY one on threads like this. My experience tells a different story.
There is a portion of people who recover within weeks.
For this population, mind control techniques seem to work well.
The unfortunate people who do not recover in the first 2 months, normally take a solid year or longer.
This is seen in research, with heavy users taking up to 2 years for 'clinical' recovery.
Some on BL, perhaps not you, would argue that the difference between these two groups is a matter of discipline, choice, and mind-over-matter.
While there is SOME truth to this, it is also laughable.
It is much more logical to assume that the second population has true brain damage or 're-wiring'.
As a result of greater serotonin degeneration, anxiety is greatly increased and perhaps NECESSARY for the re-wiring process. I have seen MANY people make 'mind-over-matter' statements only after many MONTHS of intense suffering!
It is pretty amusing to see people that have emerged from the depths of despair to calmly conclude that they fixed it through mind-control. It is more likely that months of suffering ALLOWED them to reach a state of mind-control. Not the other way around.
Those just beginning the journey deserve an honest account of just how BAD it really is.
Not jut how easy it becomes after a YEAR.
I see the SAME behavior in a group of former SSRI users that I listen in on.
The ones just beginning are OBSESSED with every symptom and treatment.
Seeing them go back and forth is eerily similar to the MDMA users I have counseled.
Once they pass the one year mark, maybe 18 months, they tend to make statements about 'mind-over-matter' and just remaining calm.
It is the suffering and anxiety over TIME that allows the brain to calm down.
Not just force of will.
Those that can exert this behavior early on, arguably are NOT experiencing the same level of 'brain damage' as the rest.
For this reason I normally tell OPs like this one that they will probably recover within 2-3 months.
If they don't, it looks like 1-1.5 years is the trend.
Then I give them, and other readers, valid and
alarming scientific data and anecdotal experience.
Threads like these are not only meant to argue mind-over-matter...
There is a greater purpose, and it does indeed lead to harm-reduction.
Your statement about not liking cannabis after heavy MDMA use is the greatest evidence that it did change you. Heavy cannabis users can experience this phenomena in the absence of other drugs, but MDMA has a talent for destroying the positive effects of smoking pot.
My greatest panic attacks this year arrived just after smoking, including one that involved a suspected stroke! In my opinion...
Cannabis and most drugs rely on the brain having an EVEN blood distribution.
If blood perfusion is not close to average in ALL brain regions, then the effects of the drug are changed.
Like a symphony that is out of sync, some regions of the brain are in discord with the rest.
The THC is not carried into all relevant pathways, and the subsequent release from the endocrine system also does not strike the right notes.
MDMA causes decreases in regional brain blood perfusion for many weeks/months.
MDMA can cause increases as well, which are considered hallmark signs of neurotoxicity and the 're-wiring' of the brain. This can take over a YEAR.
Serotonin has powerful effects on cerebro-microvasculature, or small blood vessels in the brain.
And cannabis does increase serotonin in the brain.
Altered serotonin transmission and blood vessel distribution does indeed cause PANIC attacks or anxiety when cannabis is used.
And it sucks.