@jose ribas da silva that's some good information about Brazil that I hadn't known before, as far as that one post above with all these different transitional periods. Brazil certainly seems to be one of a number of different countries which just has a very unstable and painful history that has led to a lot of hardship for its' people.
Yeah, I think maybe you understand a bit more what I had in mind with how I would want to see drugs legalized/decriminalized.
To be a bit more specific, there would be a number of different conditions that would need to be in place to legally buy drugs in my ideal society, and even more conditions to sell them.
For example, I don't really fully understand how the social security system works in the United States, let alone in Brazil or other countries, but one thing I do know is that there are a lot of different things you cannot legally do in the United States if you do not have a social security number. For example, you cannot legally work in the United States without one, and at least one of these reasons is that I am pretty sure you cannot pay taxes if you don't have a social security number, and of course dodging taxes is illegal.
Now, I've had a social security number for as long as I can remember, and I'm honestly not sure when I first got one. My parents probably set me up with one when I was a baby, but to be honest I don't know, and i don't know what one has to do to get a social security number and card if one does not have one, but I do know that a large percentage of homeless people in the United States don't have social security numbers.
So basically, having a social security number and card means in the United States that you exist on paper as a U.S. citizen.
So, in the system I am talking about, in order to be able to legally buy or sell drugs you would need to have a social security number and card, pay taxes yearly, and have a valid form of identification, whether or not it is a driver's license, and be at least 18 years old.
And as far as being able to be a licensed seller/drug dealer when it comes to these drugs, in my perfect system you would need to jump through a whole lot more legal hoops to be able to get a dealer's license.
I am not sure what a licensed dealer would have to do to become one in my perfect system, but it would be something similar to what people have to do to get liquor licenses to work in liquor stores, and they would have to take some kind of long course and pass it, get registered by the U.S. government as a seller, etc, and of course be a legal adult at least 18 years old or older.
Then of course, when one of these dealers gets their license it would not allow them to sell drugs on the street, only in the store that they work in, and only to people who have social security numbers, valid IDs who pay taxes and are of legal age, etc etc etc.
In my system, if you were to sell drugs without having a license you would get arrested and in a lot of legal trouble, but not the same level or kind of legal trouble you get in right now for selling drugs illegally, not like years and years or life in prison, but it would still be serious.
Someone who did that would have to pay VERY serious fines and spend probably several years in prison, but it would be more like the kind of prison time a person does for not paying their taxes or for operating a business illegally or money laundering etc: the people they would be imprisoned with would NOT be violent criminals, murderers, rapists, pedophiles or armed robbers, but more like thieves, burglars, tax evaders, money launderers, those who sell fake IDs, etc etc.
Then the people who buy drugs illegally from those who are not licensed sellers would not get NEARLY the kind of convictions they get now, and most would probably get very heavy fines and only do jail time if they could not pay their fines.
The kind of time they did would be
more like JAIL time than PRISON time: mostly put in holding cells until they can post bail or pay for their fines, and they'd be in jail just with petty thieves, those who drove drunk, those who vandalize or do graffiti or disturb the public, etc.
The reason they'd be in prison would really not be because they were doing anything wrong by having or buying the drug, but only because by not buying it through the proper system they would be supporting an untaxed dealer which is not ok.
Then lets say a kid under the age of 18 buys drugs illegally, or period from anyone, he would probably just get put in juvenile detention, no big deal.
And the kinds of kids you are talking about in Brazil, the 12 year olds with the AK-47s who sell drugs to people in the favelas? Those kids would just get locked up in juvenile detentions for like a year and probably made to take school classes while locked up and not permitted back onto the streets until they have a safe legal guardian.
So under this system, all the people you are talking about, the kids who sell the drugs in the favelas and the people who buy from them, ANYONE who is selling these drugs that does not have a license to sell, anyone who is not buying from someone with a license ALL THOSE PEOPLE WOULD BE ARRESTED AND PUT IN JAIL, but it would not be the kind of serious prison time it is now.
I mean basically, all those people in the favelas that you are talking about, how many of them have social security numbers, valid IDs and pay taxes and are part of a yearly census where the government keeps track of who they are and where they live, etc??
Probably not many right?
Just like in the U.S., probably 95% or more of those people living in the slums or on the streets or who are part of gangs do not have social security numbers, do not pay taxes, and are unaccounted for by the government, so those people would be put in jail.
Basically, not having a social security number might even be a crime in itself.
Right now I know it is not a crime not to have one in the U.S, but at the same time you cannot legally work or pay taxes, so honestly, I am not really sure why it isn't illegal not to have one.
Anyways, the point is, that my idea is that you would have to be part of a system to buy these drugs and have a social security number and pay taxes and have your name in a government computer verifying your identity and all that stuff.
Then if you are of legal age and you pay taxes and have social security number and go through the entire process to become a legal drug dealer, then you can sell those drugs, and if you do the same things then you can buy from a licensed dealer.
I honestly believe that it would be WAY WAY better if we had legalized drugs under a system like this, and I really don't see why people of legal age who pay taxes and are part of the system should not be allowed to buy any drug they want so long as they use the drug in the privacy of their own homes and don't drive while high.
These are the same kinds of laws they have in places like Amsterdam right now.
I went to Amsterdam 15 years ago and bought and smoked weed and bought and took shrooms legally in coffee shops, but there was one kid who tried to sell weed to me once in a park and I didn't buy from him.
He was totally selling weed illegally and would have gotten arrested cause he had no dealer's license.
It's the same in the U.S. when it comes to liquor and cigarettes: you can be arrested for just making your own liquor or beer and selling it on the street or going and buying a pack of cigarettes and then selling them to people.
It would just be the same thing for selling or buying drugs without doing it legally, but it wouldn't be because the drugs themselves are illegal, but just because you aren't following the proper protocol when buying or selling.