Sadly I think it's even simpler than that. A lot of people who use LSD and other psychedelics tend toward empathy, nonviolence, acceptance of unusual or nonstandard thinking, and a whole host of other thought processes that those in power don't understand and find threatening. Or to simplify even further, being open minded undermines authority. It really is that simple. I don't think there's a conspiracy so much as a self replicating machine made out of terrified authority figures who think psychedelics are going to destroy the system they're comfortable in.
Any of y'all familiar with Herbert Marcuse's One Dimensional Man? In it, he refutes both capitalism and communism both as enslaving people, through either tyranny or consumption of material goods, which leave people "One Dimensional". It was a major work back in the 1960s when shit started hittin the fan and some people started waking up.
Perhaps if a hundred other chemists had those mental effects they would've either shrugged them off or disregarded them. Perhaps they awoke something in Hoffman that resonated with his human nature.
Everyone always says "there's no evidence that kykeon was psychedelic" but seriously, most of what they drank back then was beer and wines made from lots of different plants that get ergot fungus on them.
and you pretty much can't deny that there's a very good chance some guy made some barleywine that he didn't know ergot was growing on and had a mystical experience and started a religion from it.
Theres this one guy who made a theory that Beowulf came from "barleywolf" implying that he likely drank ergot infused barleywine
that's an interesting question. i often wonder if the 'prototypical' psychs/empathogen/any drug class are so just because of historical value rather than anything
what if the APB's were discobered before MDMA, and then people found MDMA to be bad because it wasn't so stimulating or because of the horrible comedowns with often weird side effects
humm
^^ For anyone interested, wether kykeon was an ergot containing drug or not, is discussed at length in this thread in dmt-nexus:
https://www.dmt-nexus.me/forum/default.aspx?g=posts&t=8051
Personally I don't believe the hypothesis because I find it unlikely, and regardless of that, there is no hard archeological evidence of it! Until we have that, the hypothesis can't move past that point and all kinds of argumentation and speculation is kind of pointless.
I do appreciate it would be pretty awesome if the ancient greeks drank an ergot containing brew. Just like it would be pretty awesome if the vikings and the celts had used psychedelic mushrooms. Unfortunately there is absolutely no evidence of that either.
The only psychedelic drugs we have archeological evidence of having been known and used in antique Europe are deliriants. Atropa belladonna, henbane and different datura's. The roman ladies used belladona as eyedrops to dilate their pupils to look more beautiful (which is why it's called belladonna = beautiful lady) and as a poison.
And henbane seeds have been found in a purse in a viking seeress' grave, for instance. So, that is hard archeological evidence that the viking seeress' (the Vǫlva) used henbane for divination. Some henbane were also found in 2900 year old pots at Balfarg henge, Scotland. Unfortunately analysis was inconclusive.
Anyway, Kykeon is like Soma - it's very unlikely we will never know what it really contained.
In my opinion, discusions on the historic use of psychedelics, in PD, mostly venture into fantasy and wishfullthinking, aka:
"I'm sure the druids used magic mushrooms, man, how could they not have! they grow all over the UK.....and the druids were like, you know, some kind of feral hippies, it's impossible they didn't use 'em, man.....and celtic artwork is like, so psychedelic...." etc, etc...
And yes, I'm aware there's a 10.000 years old cave painting of something that looks like mushrooms yada yada yaaaa..