I completely agree with dexter_stayne. I am finding more and more often that pill ratings do not provide a very accurate indication of how good/bad a pill is, as you don't really know what tolerance that person has, what other drugs they have mixed with the pill they have rated (weed, alcohol, speed, etc), or what they expect as a good bikkie (eg. 'put me on my ass, must have been K, 1/10' when that may well have been MDMA or, 'danced all night, couldn't sleep for days, 9/10' - most likely speed).
The ever increasingly poor level of description of the effects, and of the pill itself, only adds to the frustration!
I'm always fairly critical of the pill in question when I'm rating it, and I don't think I've ever given anything more than an 8/10, even when I've wanted to. To be honest, the longest peak I've ever had would be around 3 hours - I wish I could get onto this 5+ hour peak business! =)
As for Melbourne pills at the moment - I'm having a fair degree of difficulty getting my hands on some quality pills. Recently tested the likes of Octogons, Suns, Sunrise's/set's, Bacardis, and Hearts and nothing has stood out as a winner. Munched a Barcardi and thought it was fairly average
Must admit I havn't tried any of the 3's though - just can't find any! Think I must have the wrong contacts :/
doofhard: I think its unfair that you are finding all the quality biscuts in Melbourne - send some over my way! =)
Cheers,
erokr