PinholeStar said:
The name that immediately sprang to mind though when I saw this thread was Gene Hackman. The man is consistently great in everything he's in, & is one of the most watchable actors around, for my money.
This is one of those instances where I *know* that people who know far more about acting than I do just about universally agree on Hackman's greatness (even as I maintain my stance that he's a consistently "very good" actor, though I've hardly
ever been bowled over any of his performances to the point where I exited the movie thinking "This Guy Deserves The Oscar for Best Actor this year!" (with the notable recent exception of
The Royal Tenenbaums).
To be honest, I personaly feel that while he certainly is a very good dramatic actor, his greatest strength may be in the more-challenging (imo, obviously) realm of high-level comedy.
With my non-idolization of Hackman noted, James Lipton, in as-non-gushing-as-is-possible-for-him manner, shared with Hackman a very impressive statstic during Hackman's episode of
Inside The Actors Studio.
A show which, by the way, in my opinion, is SEVERELY underrated - say what you will about Lipton's penchant for overdoing it on the ass-kissing, but in my opinion, for all of the interviewers of celebrities today, he (and his forum) provide for BY FAR the gretatest insight into each of its guests' lives and careers (Charlie Rose is excellent too, but he often wastes his time speaking to irrelevant non-movie stars like presidents of countries and authors of . . . I think the word is "books.").
In any case, I feel that many people are too quick to indict the in-my-opinion-adorable-Lipton, who, for my money performs SIX of the most important interviewing skills extremely well:
(1) The quality of his research is simply unparallelled;
(2) He asks well-thought-out questions whose answers really tell us about what makes the man (or woman) the man (or woman) he (or she) is, as opposed to wasting precious time going on about US Weekly/Oprah-level "news" ;
(3) He frames the interview chronologically, so the viewer can actually see in what specific ways a (usually) now-well-respected-world-famous actor was influenced and how he or she dealt with certain obstacles that would have no doubt, been success-killers for most of us.
(4) After asking each question, he actually shuts the fuck up, and lets his interviewee be the star of his or her show; and most importantly . . .
(5) He actually LISTENS to the answers to his questions, which leads to better follow-up questions, and also, makes his guests feel more at ease, so that they eventually feel sufficiently comfortable to be more candid than they otherwise would have been willing to be;
and although some might not consider this a good thing, I most certainly do:
(6) The man is not a fucking question-asking robot.
He actually has emotions and is not afraid to show them.
Call me a metrosexual, but I actually like him and respect him for that.
And, no - I don't think he's "acting."
I simply perceive this as a case of someone who despite very possibly wanting very badly all throughout his younger years to eventually become a successful actor, he unfortunately (at the time) lacked the combination of looks and perhaps talent to become a superstar actor himself . . .
. . . and is now, as a result, probably pinching himself every day because he now has the oppotunity to particpate in genuine heart-to-heart dialogues with some of the gretaest players in the field he is most passionate about.
I apologize for that War And Peace-length aside about Lipton . . .
. . . and while admittedly, to quote Tarantino's character in the Fourth Room, "I kind of went around the world" on this post, my point in bringing Lipton up is this:
Even though, in my opinion, Hackman is consistently very good, but is rarely upper-echelon-level great, on Hackman's
Inside The Actor's Studio episode, Lipton gushingly informed Hackman that of the 100 or so (mostly) well-respected actors who were guests on Lipton's show beforehand, more had named Hackman as an important influence on their respective careers than any other actor ever.
And that's gotta count for something.