• ✍️ WORDS ✍️

    Welcome Guest!

  • Words Moderators: Shambles

Untitled short piece. Please critique?

chandler

Bluelighter
Joined
Oct 14, 2004
Messages
712
Unedited. Wrote in about half an hour. First creative piece. Any thoughts would be great.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
He stared longingly at the ashtray, cigarettes butts ejecting in every-which-way direction like some sort of bizarre fungus. Except uglier. The way in which they reared their burnt orange heads was a reflection of something deeper. His inability to ever get around to emptying it, and the collection of dirty ash peppering the desk like a fine moss was an all too distinct metaphor for the greater portion of his life.

"Fuck it" he said, largely under his breath, but audible to anyone within touching distance. It was her again. Always her. "Her" changed occasionally, but despite the exact form of "her", she always managed to crawl into his thoughts. It was nearly 4pm. The old urges were slowly creeping around. Weekends were now a 48 hour period of indistinguishable momentum. Day, night and in between were essentially irrelevant when seven-eighths of the weekend was spent under the influence of something, and daytime was an inconvenience, pent up in a darkened room in front of a screen. Why was it her? What had drawn him so strongly to her?

She was pure. Pure enough. Yet to become so jaded with one’s self-view that she’d lost all hope. He wasn’t. She was drawn to something. That glimmer of good he could show. Same old story. It never changed. Nothing draws them in more than a charity case. Except for a charity case where, deep down somewhere far in their heart, they don’t honestly believe he’s that bad. He was drawn to something. Something he can’t have became something he shouldn’t have became something he had. The hooks were in on both of them. Same old story. Friend’s girlfriend, colleague, best friend, what did it matter...? Labels were unnecessary. He just enjoyed doing what he shouldn’t. Now he was so deep respite was a foreign concept. It played on his mind day and night.

Despite his feelings, he’d been overjoyed when she finally left the previous afternoon. Her company, like most, was a source of savoured pleasure, so long as he was drunk. He woke up the following morning with the usual sense of self-loathing that goes hand in hand with the crash of sobriety. Physical and psychological ugliness grew heavy and all-encompassing as she lay by his side. Why wouldn’t she just leave? Something beautiful didn’t belong in the sea of ash, empty bottles and half-formed goodwill that were his bedroom.

His mind grew back to the ashtray. Unable to bring himself to empty it, gathering an odd degree of satisfaction from every bit of disgusting it represented. There was a reason he surrounded himself with filth. It felt comfortable. Conforming to what his life had slowly become. He slowly placed another cigarette in his mouth, and went to light it. The sun was finally setting. Not long now. It was just a question of what…
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
This is pretty good, especially for a first write.

I love this line:

Something beautiful didn’t belong in the sea of ash, empty bottles and half-formed goodwill that were his bedroom.
And the ending too:

The sun was finally setting. Not long now. It was just a question of what…
First rule of writing fiction though, is: show, don't tell. As in, show what is happening to the characters, and what sort of people they are, by describing scenes and actions, and using dialogue, rather than directly 'explaining' who a character is.

Don't get me wrong, you've made a good start, and you have incorporated some vivid description, with the ashtray, his bedroom, etc. I think we need to hear more about 'her' though, and perhaps you could introduce a scene where the two of them interact, even if it's only relived in his memory?
 
Thanks for the kind words! I understand what you mean with the show/tell pointer... Food for thought.

Coming from business school, I've never had the opportunity to write anything formally. Hoping to finish off with a couple of writing subjects this semester. It felt good to try my hand at something flowing from my mind rather than a 30 page report for work...

If the words come to me over the next couple of days, I'll add another part. This one was a spur of the moment thing brought on by an experience, semi-autobiographical.


Thanks again.

Edit: Just threw this out... Once again, no real editing/rereading. Twenty minute stream of consciousness.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The memories were gently mulling in his mind; foggy yet clear, uplifting yet soul-crushingly negative. The unremitting thought that he shouldn’t have done it, weighed heavily against lofty notions of like - or even love. He didn’t doubt her feelings, only his own. She was genuine; he’d somehow lost faith in his ability to feel anything real amidst the sea of intoxication, work and otherworldly concerns. Before they had really connected, he flirted with a future as she walked carelessly around the office.

What if this could actually become something?

The constant thought that she was better than him only served to further reinforce the idea of the unattainable. Her innocence was so far removed from his dried up, jaded perceptions of all that became his world. He enjoyed letting aspirations run through his mind, then sharply pulling them out like ingrained hairs. Now that they’d been together, he quietly chuckled at the thought, likening it to the daily ritual at the liquor store. It had become routine – relishing the shortlived levity he could only attain on the way there, and in the dying moments before he poured the first glass. Once it entered his system, it became joyless. The sense of self-doubt was so strong that developing this metaphor in his head was easier than actually accepting the possibility of something good.

Unremarkably, the night that they first kissed was hazy and blurred - a combination of his staggered drunkenness and diminished memory from the past few years of abuse. Moments of clarity shot through the stupor, the way she gently pressed her head on his back, as he pressed the bottle to his lips, the music fading away when their eyes finally crossed, softly rubbing her hand as they both finally gave up resisting. For seconds, minutes, maybe an hour, he managed to disregard the inherent problems of life that plagued his daily thoughts. She managed to drift off into a better place, amidst the noise and clutter, feeling wanted and loved.

The second time was much the same, only far more intense. The mutual desire had grown stronger, and once again, he’d cheapened it with alcohol. It was his way of bringing it to his level - a methodical procedure with which he could actively distance himself from truly enjoying a moment. That was for other people. As they entered his room, he awaited the instant judgment the throng of beer bottles and cigarette butts would bring. It didn’t come.

Why didn’t she care? Couldn’t she see this as a reflection of him?

As they lay down into the bed, a culmination of limbs, bodies, lips and emotion, they both forgot. About it all. The memories ceased from then on, as he woke up to the morning light, feeling the heavy burden of the night before exercising heavily on his body. Dry mouth, pounding head, overwhelming guilt. The mess of his room was even more evident in the daylight. He glanced at the surging ashtray, hoping she’d miss it amongst the masses of empty bottles. She didn’t miss it. And she didn’t care.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Last edited:
i liked the first piece enough that i actually want to edit it. i might come back later and do so, just for fun... in the second, i got to the word "juxtaposed" and cried... i hate that word sorry, i might read the rest later.
 
Hahaha! Gold... I actually cringed when i wrote it! As I said, off the cuff, and I aint no writer.

Juxtaposed is so year 10 english... ;) Consider it bunted out.

And I'd be delighted if you wanted to edit it.
 
Last edited:
Top