Tyrosone/Phenylalanine Tolerance
Tommy, your tyrosine response resonates with me. I believe Tyrosine/Phenylalanine has a huge your-mileage-may-vary component, for whatever reason based on responses in me vs. in other people.
Around 1990, when I was a teen-ager, my father had just finished going back to school for a second degree in engineering (after spending most of his life as a mechanic). As an older person, he found calculus & physics to be more challenging the second time around, compared to his younger days. He heard about phenylalanine & choline, tried them, and found them to be a miracle for getting through his classes. So he recommended that I try it, and being a teenager, I responded "yeah, whatever".
So I tried it, very skeptically. It was because of my phenylalanine response that I'm an avid supplement user until this day (many other supplements have joined the list, all for the good). There was a point in the response where it was impossible to deny that something was going on. I'm sure that people who try cocaine, meth, marijuana, LSD, etc, will laugh if you seriously argue to them "it's probably placebo". It was the same kind of clear sensation.
I switched from being pure introvert to being the center of attention and quite funny. I felt very alive, and occasionally actually high. It lasted for maybe 9 months to 1 year. Eventually, the stuff would no longer work. Not like withdrawals or addiction or whatever, just stopped working.
I believe it left me with a permanent change for the good, although the major effects faded. I stopped taking it about 15 years ago, and every now and then will try it, to no avail. My body got what it wanted, and it's done with it.
Like you, I'm deeply curious about the mechanism. I've tried just about every other brain supplement since, and many work well and continue to work for me, without this kind of tolerance issue. But none are the level of intensity and effectiveness that phenylalanine (or tyrosine also) had for me.
I've recommended phenylalanine to at least 5 different people. None had the response that I had. Some said it made them irritable/aggresive. Many said no effect. One saw a mild positive effect. It's crazy to me, because the effect should definately be noticeable, according to my experience.
So my conclusion is that rather than me developing a tolerance, I probably had a kind of defeciency. I think it kind of explains some of my pre-teen misfit/dorky behavior, which straightened out post phenylalanine.