The Greatest Quarterback Ever looked pretty fucking good to me.
He had an inferior supporting cast, and admittedly, he threw ONE bad pass in an important situation.
I'm disappointed that he didn't quite pull through, against an excellent Saints team who played VERY well - but "pretty ordinary?"
Even after Sunday's loss, Manning is STILL on pace to break just about every single career passing record, and already has an NFL record 4 MVP's, and has (so far) 2 Super Bowl Appearances, and 1 Super Bowl Win.
He still has a title or two more he needs to win in order to cement his place as The Best Football Player I've Ever Seen . . .
. . . but, with that said, in the 5-7 additional seasons he is likely to play, I would expect him to do exactly that.
Oh yeah - and he's the first de facto head coach/quarterback in the history of the NFL - that should certainly count for something - it's game-changing.
All of that said - CONGRATS SAINTS & THEIR FANS!