sekio
Bluelight Crew
How does the saying go - "minds are what brains do?"
Yeh, except they are different things. The brain is the physical component, part of the body, to which the mind interfaces with, or sits in like a rider in a chariot.. they both clearly relate to each other and affecting change in one can cause effects in the other. But the mind is not some physical thing like the brain. Thoughts, emotions, these are transcendent things that show up as responses in the brain but they're not in the brain.
Like the ProphettoProfit mentioned about the screen.. our brains receive signals from our sensory apparatus and reconstruct this data. But where are we "seeing" or "hearing"? We're not actually seeing what is there, only a reconstruction. Even if you take reductionist thinking the brain takes in this data and then constructs this world we "see".. but again where do we see? There is no light in the brain, no image in the brain, just electrical activity. So again, where are we seeing this reconstructed world before us?
The same goes for imagination. Right now I can imagine a blue sports car and I can see it pretty clearly. Where is this image taking place? There is surely electrical activity happening in the brain but again there is no light, no image to be found, and yet I can witness this image quite clearly. This image is being projected upon something, from which I can then witness it.
The bit about OBE's/AP.. "nothing more than tricks".. this is "nothing more" than reductionist thinking. It happens, it's real, and it needs more investigation. "Tricks" is not a sufficient explanation.
http://gizmodo.com/5843117/scientists-reconstruct-video-clips-from-brain-activity
And there's plenty more examples that I cba to dig up of brain activity being decoded. Thoughts, feelings, ideas and everything in between..
The mind is a product of the brain.
The image you "see" when imagining a car is being created by and perceived by the most complex thing known to man.. the human brain.. (That real life physical thing inside your head).. It's only a matter of time before we are able to decode a brain and recreate your imagined images..
And you're right, OBE's are real.. but the idea that "people" actually leave their body and SEE (without their eyes or brains) is.. well.. bullshit.