• Welcome Guest

    Forum Guidelines Bluelight Rules
    Fun 💃 Threads Overdosed? Click
    D R U G   C U L T U R E

Ppl who think NA/AA sucks:How would u do it better?How would YOUR ideal program work?

Khadijah

Bluelight Crew
Joined
Dec 18, 2003
Messages
16,368
Location
Hell
The title says it all. If it was up to you, how would you run a program like NA? Wat would be the main ideas? How would it be different than the 12 step programs that already exist? this is a thread to post about the idea of doin "recovery" YOUR way. Lots of us got problems with NA/AA for many different reasons, but there aint really a alternative. If you could create one, how would it work?

Whether you got a problem with the "powerless" concept and believe that you need willpower and discipline to get clean....Or you think that total and complete abstinence from EVERYTHING is unnecessary and believe that there aint nothin wrong with a dopehead who got clean smoking weed....Maybe you think that somebody who is a addict, CAN use successfully, in moderation without it forcing them to go straight back into addiction--share it here. Those ideas are the type of shit that this thread is askin about. Anybody who ever been to a meeting, who thought "thats bullshit, that aint gonna get you better, you gotta _________ instead" , here is the spot to post that "instead". Basically, Im askin, if you had your own rehab or treatment center that teaches people how to break free from their addiction(s), wat would you teach?

here is some questions to get you started:
  • Can a successful recovery still involve drug use of any kind, or not? Why or why not?
  • Is medication therapy, like methadone/suboxone therapy, a part of your program, or do you discourage all replacement therapy and believe that to be clean you gotta be off meth/sub?
  • Does your program require total abstinence from ALL drugs to be considered "clean"? or only the drug that the person was addicted to? or can they even use their DOC as long as its reponsibly?
  • In your program, If an addict uses drugs, is all use=abuse, by definition, becuz they are an addict?
  • Wat is more important when it comes to bein "clean", your mindset and your mentality about drug use, or your physical actions? (for example, in your program who would be considered more successful: The addict who dont use no drugs at all but who struggles every day to not get high, whose mentality is still the same as it was when he was using, who still thinks like a junkie but is just not actively using and is miserable without the drugs and mentally unhealthy--or the addict who stopped abusing his DOC, who stopped thinking like a addict and completely got rid of the 'junkie mindset' , who is very content and happy with life, who still occasionally uses the drug he was addicted to?)

I know this aint the typical DC thread and it might involve a lil bit more thought than the average thread, but i really hope that yall will still take a minute and reply. cuz i am really interested to see yalls ideas. I got plenty of my own that i will come back and post later so i hope that yall will add to it too. Lots of us have bitched about NA on here so lets take it one step farther and come up with somethin better.
 
well lacey i found it pointless to go NA meetings tho i lately started to go there while high just for fun. imo its pointless all they do is talk about drug related shit and cop stories and personal issues. its so pathetic. for me i found goin to p-doc regularly is much more helpful than NA.

plus its kinda dangerous cuz u can make connections at meetings cuz u meet new ppl, lets say someone just quit blow and have no coke source, that person may find a connection in there or meet ppl who do other drugs and they can hook each other up and shit like that.
 
Great thread idea!

Personally, I would like to manipulate THE program to suit myself and make it MY program. I'd love to see what folks come up with. Despite my familiarity with NA, I am stuck on the flaws in it that apply to me personally and haven't really put much thought into alternatives.

This is gonna be good... thanks lacey
 
From what I have seen the dropout rate for AA and NA is more then 75 percent. Most people are there for a month or 2 then they complete IOP and go back to getting high. So yeah it is a damn good place to meet connections but so is everywhere else drug users congregate.
 
I really don't think any program will work all that well unless we change some perceptions of society as well as legal barriers. Whether it be 12 step, rational recovery, your own personal philosophy, the law hinders progress far too much to provide any benefit

that being said, I think an ideal program would have to be tailored according to each individual and their wants, needs, and desires. I think total abstinence is an unnecessary and ridiculous concept. A major issue I have with 12 step programs is how they lump all substances together. Opiates are different from psychedelics, which are different from alcohol, etc etc etc. I personally find smoking weed, especially high quality weed, works wonders when coming off of opiates for myself. Not only does it minimize and eliminate many withdrawal symptoms, good weed actually feels similar to an opiate high in a number of ways for me. That being said, I also believe strongly that maintainence programs of some sort can be miracles. Ultimately I believe functionality as well as happiness are the keys to eliminating/controlling addiction. If someone wants to use heroin, and they are completely functional and content for the most part doing so, why should they not be allowed access to a pure, safe product with safeguards in place? Eliminating the dangerous nature of street drugs would completely change the perception of a drug. The biggest dangers associated with heroin use are due mostly to the unpredictable nature of the black market and unsafe usage practices. If people could get a pharmaceutically pure product, which could be measured in standard dosages and administered with safe and sterile equipment, heroin use could arguably be safer than alcohol or tobacco use to the body

The nature of use, abuse, and addiction are far too subjective to place any kind of category on. Same goes for the term clean. I tend to take a vague interpretation to all of these terms, as in it's up to the individual to decide. It isn't anyone but the users place to say whether or not they are addicted, whether or not their usage is abusive in nature, what constitutes them being clean, and so on and so forth. My personal belief is a person becomes an addict when their use brings about dysfunction in their lives as a result of their using and their using alone. If someone shoots dope every hour on the hour, but is able to function, live their life, and be generally content, then who's to say they are an addict? Likewise, if someone shoots up once a day or less, yet this leads to a negative impact on their lives, what would you consider them? Especially in relation to a frequent user? Economics are also a heavily weighing factor. One could be a chain smoker, or even a heavy drinker, and be able to support themselves financially with little problem. On the other hand, someone who is a heroin user will be paying more to get their substance of choice due to many mitigating factors. If their DOC was as cheap and available as nicotine, tobacco, caffeine, or alcohol, would they have the same issues?

I know personally I love using heroin. If I could have my choice, I would have enough to fix up at any point in the day I so chose. That being said, if I have an obligation such as work, or a family get together, or I need to drive, I don't want to be on a heavy nod. I have always been one to regulate my drug use so that the actual effects of the drug do not have a negative impact on things I need to do in life. Despite this, 12 steppers and NA types would undoubtedly label me as an addict. Even if I were to view myself as one, I would take much more pride in being a functional addict than being someone who is clean and highly dysfunctional and unable to operate. Furthermore, I hate the generalizations of drug use. I have panic attacks on occasion, as well as high anxiety. Sometimes I enjoy taking a benzo, and other times I find it necessary. I've been given crap countless times by 12 steppers and people in rehab settings about benzo usage. During one of my stays at a clinic, I was given klonopin, a medicine I am prescribed on the outside, during the detox phase. After detox, they would not give it to me. Now I went in telling them I am a frequent heroin user. I use benzos on very rare and sporadic occasions, and I never use them if I think they will cause me to be too drowsy either that day or the next to accomplish tasks. Despite my self control, and my extreme awareness and fear of benzo dependence and withdrawal, they would not give me klonopin. And why is this? Because it is an "addictive medicine". I find this to be horseshit. On the same token, I am really not a nicotine smoker. I will smoke maybe once every few months, and will not smoke in a rehabilitation setting. So why is it that I am lumped as an addict with people who are heavy chain smokers when I pride myself on not smoking any at all? Likewise, I am told by these types I am the same as an alcoholic. I really do not like alcohol. I will drink alcohol once every few months, and very rarely do I get drunk. I will never even get buzzed if I am going to be driving, and prefer to be a designated driver to people. Why is it that despite this, I get categorized and labelled in the same group as someone who needs to down hard liquor every morning in order to keep from getting the shakes?

Ultimately, I feel our current system operates the exact opposite of how it needs to. It isn't up to anyone but the individual to decide what constitutes a problem, what is abuse and addiction, what clean entails, and what would be best in their lives. By categorizing and generalizing, this system and the 12 step monopoly fails to realize every person is different. It focuses so heavily on promoting collective thought, categorizations, and labels that it fails to take into account the unique nature of every person and the fact that no two people have the exact same situation in life, no matter how many factors may overlap in their experiences. If the 12 steps, NA, AA, or rehabs work for some, then that's wonderful for them, and I wish the best of luck. To subject me or someone else who thinks that said philosophies are a load of shit in their mind to that kind of program is counterproductive. I have never actually attended any type of rehab setting for myself. It has always been either to try and impress/satisfy family and ones close to me, or in order to look good for pending legal situations(all of which center around possession, nothing else). Personally, if I could put myself on a heroin maintainence program, I'd do so in a heartbeat. Ideally the unrestricted access to a completely free market in drugs would be the ideal for me, but the likelihood of that occurring is about the same as it raining $100 dollar bills from the sky. The less we promote collective thinking, ignorant societal taboos and beliefs regarding drugs, and the current monopoly 12 step thinking and the disease model of addiction has over the entire recovery racket and legal system, and promote individualized approaches towards addiction and drug use, the more successful we will ultimately be at handling the true nature of addiction and abuse within society as well as addressing the true concerns of people

great topic, apologies if I ramble on in my response or it is too long, but I have much to say and strong opinions on this topic. I could probably write a book on this whole topic :D
 
Thanks overdone and evilthree for your replies....

Just tryna remind yall--This thread aint "How do you feel about NA, bitch here", so please dont post your comments of how you feel about the program in this thread. that aint wat its for. If you wanna do that, we can have a thread about the 12 steps , thats cool, but in here , that aint the topic.

Anyways, i agree that there aint no one specific program that will work for everybody. But I think that somethin that is general enough, that offers enough room for people to kinda make it their own, could be helpful to folks. If instead of bein so cut and dry it was more like just a general set of recommendations to people, SUGGESTIONS, that might help them...that might do people some good.

For example heres some shit that Ive learned over the past year of bein clean.

(And when i say i been clean, i mean, there wasnt one time when i was addicted to dope. I used maybe 5 times total over the last year. All of them was for one day at a time, i got high that day and that was it. I didnt do nothing risky to get my dope like copping-didnt get it on the street. i didnt shoot up in bathrooms or no shit like that, i waited til i got home to do it safely. i used all clean and brand new materials, new sets, clean water, clean cottons, etc. I mighta got high, but i didnt do it in a junkie, addict way. You feel me, that is the difference. and so easch time i got high, no i didnt start counting from the beginning again. becuz i WASNT back at the beginning, i didnt lose all the progress i had made--i didnt "fall off" and make a mistake. each time i got high it was carefully planned well thought out and a conscious decision that i knew about at least a week ahead of time each time. It wasnt a slip, or a relapse, or nothing like that. So there aint no reason to go count from day 1 again, cuz i wasnt there.)

So anyways after that lil explanation....

here is my "basic ideas for not bein a drug addict, and livin a happy life-watever that means to you."

IDEA #1 -- i think that a person who is addicted to dope, or watever, aint necessisarily addicted to other shit. If you got a problem with alcohol, it dont mean that you are gonna overdo the painkillers when you get them prescribed. If you got a issue with dope, it dont mean that you will sniff up all the coke anytime you get a chance. If you are a cokehead, it dont mean you gonna be drinking like crazy as soon as you get a drop in you.

Sure people can be addicted to more than one thing. but addiction to one thing, DONT mean that you are automatically just "addictive personality" and will be addicted to eVERYTHING, like the programs these days say.

Im the same as u evilthree--I dont like drinkin. I rarely, ever, ever drink. Seriously mabye like 2 or 3 times a year at the most, and its usually one drink , at a wedding or some shit like that when they do the champagne toast or w/ever. I never , ever go out of control on alcohol. I aint got no desire to, and even once i get a buzz on (if i ever even drink enough to get that far) i am still totally under control, and dont got no desire to just keep poundin em back. I aint got NOTHING IN COMMON with a alcoholic--its 2 very different things. Sure both additions, but the lifestyle, the mentality, all that shit, is very different. And I aint got a drinking problem. I am totaly, completrely out of place in a AA meeting, and i also hate how the programs claim to be inter changeable.

IDEA # 2 -- I would tell anybody who got involved in my 'program'...hey, you want to smoke weed? smoke weed. right now, your main goal, is tryin to live a life that aint totally dominated by heroin addiction, that is your concern, so its ok if you smoke a little bud, jeez. weed aint dope. Marijuana is a medicinal plant that got soooo much potential to help you , in so many ways. It would be a important part of my program that if people got access to bud, I would actually recommend it. For me it always helped me when i was kickin dope, so much more than anything else ever did.

Especially at the beginning of the time when you first quit usin, havin a lil blunt to the head at bed time can really quiet your mind and make you be like "damn....This aint so bad....Wats a matter with me? Why was i puttin needles in my fuckin arms? damn, I could get by with just a blunt a day, I cant believe how crazy the shti i been doing is!" It always caused that reaction in me, made me like "Yo, WTF AM I DOIN WITH MYSELF? HOLY SHIT, I AM FUCKED UP!!" and made me want to cut back on my use. it was always a very positive thing and i think the way that it gets lumped in with all the other drugs is fucked up.

IDEA #3 -- Medical use of painkillers, benzos, etc, is allowed. If you full of shit, and you faking injuries to get scripts, then obviously you got to re consider that shit. but if you LEGTITIMATELY NEED a prescription to a "addictive substance" like benzos or opiates, and you aint abusing them, and take them as directed? Then who gives a shit? I aint no fuckin doctor, i dotn know wat the hell is wrong with you or if you deserve to have a script or not, so if your doctor thinks you need it, thats OK with me. You should not be condemned to live a life of chronic pain and suffering and misery and anxiety, just becuz you are a heroin addict. You want to stop using heroin in a way that causes problems with your life? Ok. So work on that.

Part of bein successful , is havin the other tools that you need. And for some people, who got physical conditions that cause them to be so fuckin miserable that they want to use--those tools are their medications, becuz stablizing those conditions is very important. you get the pain and anxiety out of the way so you can focus on the real problem here. otherwise you jsut gonna be distracted by all those other things and not even be abel to concentrate on your real goal.

So take the meds you need. As long as you aint abusing them, as long as you take them as prescribed and forr the purpose they prescribed for, then it aint gonna effect your recovery. We aint drug-taking machines. We aint some kind of freakish robots, that get "activated" into "take all drugs mode" when one drug goes into us. The goal here is to stop ABUSING drugs and stop being a ADDICT, not to never take another drug again entirely. which leads into the next one which is the most important one IMO.

IDEA #4 -- THE REASON AND WAY THAT YOU TAKE THE DRUGS, IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN WHETHER OR NOT YOU TAKE THEM. this is a big one . a person who uses responsibly, who aint feening for the drug, who lives a normal happy life that happens to involve occasional use of heroin or watever drug they were addicted to, is a lot more healthy IMO, than the person who is off all drugs but is miserable, and still thinks like an addict, whose life has to be all about not using becuz its such a big deal, etc.

All drug use , aint abuse. You mighta been a heroin addict. but it dont mean that automatically any time you use, that it is abuse. WHY and HOW you use, and the mindset that you are in, the way you approach it, the way you feel abot it, those are way more important. those tell you a whole lot more about whether or not a person is an addict than whether or not they use.

If you use dope becuz you sad, becuz you tryna run away from something, if you use it and mentally you are doin some Gollum shit like "my precioussss", then that aint exactly healthy. If when you use, you do risky shit, or you do risky shit in order to be able to use-- or if you DONT use, but you are constnatly thinkin about it, you are sad cuz you cant get high, you have to like seriously pay attention to every move you make so that you dont use, then you might not be usin, but you still a fuckin addict.

When i used any of those times during my past year of "clean time', my mind was so far from the mind i used to have as a junkie, its just unreal. If i am usin for teh right reasons, if i aint doin nothing risky to be able to use, if i aint doin nothing unhealthy when i use. If the reason i want to use dont involve a craving, a feening feeling, a NEED to use....If i am FREE FROM THE OBSESSION OF ADDICTION--Then that use, is absolutely not the drug use of an addict. It aint abuse.

look at some of these people in NA--They are OBSESSED WITH DRUGS! They may not be actively Using them, but they are fuckin OBSESSED yo! They sit around and go to a meeting every night, talking about drugs, about how not to use drugs. they re organize their ENTIRE LIVES, in order to avoid drugs. They MOVE ACROSS THE COUNTRY...they avoid people who they knew, who were good friends, becuz they happen to drink alcohol sometimes so they might cause them to "relapse". They make their whole entire life revolve around "recovery". they are still living their addiction. Their head is still the same inside--they even TELL themselvs that--that we are still addicts, we are the same person we used to be, so we need to keep that in check, etc. that shit, means you are still an addict.

a person who is usin healthily, recreationally, in moderation, occasionally, with a good mentality, who approaches a night with a few bundles and a fresh pack of sets the same way that they would approach a night goin out with their boys to the bar--as just a fun activity to do, have a good time, get wasted, and chill--that is way less of an addict than the non drug using obsesser.

How is a person who is living like that, whose every second of their waking life, involves thinking about how to not do drugs, and obsessing over it, considered to be healthier, than the person who occasionally, responsibly uses their DOC? I dont think that they are. and thats why the goal of this program, aint to get off drugs or to stay off them or to never use again. The goal is to learn a healthy mindset, to get yourself free from the obsessive ways of thinking and acting that you had when you were addicted, to get your head right so that you dont feel a desire to abuse drugs, and to be able to be normal and have a happy normal life again. Those are the main goals. So, if you achieve them, and at the same time you use sometimes, good for you, that is great and that is wat the program is all about.

As far as im concerned, the TRUE mark of conquering your addiction, is BEING ABLE TO USE THAT DRUG IN MODERATION. Sure, you can just TOTALLY AVOID IT becuz you cant control yourself....Or you could actually try to FIX YOURSELF....Fix the problem inside of you , the addict mentality, the junkie brain, that way of thikning, that caused you to act that way, figure out why you use to be that way and do somethin about it. once you work thru all that shit and learn how to be a normal person again, you are finally gettin somewhere. THAT is the goal--to not live a life that is obsessed with gettin high. to not NEED to get high anymore. to have a HEALTHY mind....Not to just not use drugs. Quitting all drugs aint gonna fix your fucked up head.

Instead of bein like the little kid who says 'fuck this, im taking my toys and going home, i dont wanna play no more!" learn how to compromise. its EASY to "just say no" and to never be around drugs at all. its a whole lot harder to actually be able to use that drug without goin out of control again. And once you can do that, its pretty safe to say you are a recovered addict. if you gotta avoid it, if you have to stay away from it becuz the instant you do it youll go outa control--then you aint really too far along in that recovery. if your recovery is so fragile that it can break the instant you got one milligram of oxycontin in you or one bag of dope, then it was never really all that real to begin with.



that aint all that I think about this whole thing, but i dont want to make this post so long that nobody reads it, its already logn as hell so ima leave it there for now.

and evilthree please feel free to keep writin, i read your post i dont mind that its long cuz i agree with you and i like to hear wat you got to say so dont worry about makin another long reply, write that whole book about it right here if you want to, you know that at least one person, me, is listening ;)
 
Last edited:
thanks lacey, glad you read all I wrote :)

Anyways, I feel like we have pretty much the same views on this. I think AA/NA peoples are more obsessed with drugs than many regular users and addicts out there. As I am always telling people, if I want to come off drugs, avoid a drug, or be clean, the last thing I want to do is talk about drugs and be around drug people constantly. The 12 step programs promote surrounding yourself with people who are ex addicts and in the recovery process. I personally like to be around people who have nothing to do with a drug I am trying to avoid. It makes me feel better doing activities not centered around drugs or drug people, using or sober when I want to get off of the drugs. People in the programs are ALWAYS talking about either drugs or about recovery. It's an overload many times. Furthermore, I feel like many of these people inadvertently promote relapse and a return to use, even if it isn't intentional. I know being in rehabs and in the rooms of NA make me think about using all the time. Whereas avoiding those types of settings would probably lead me to do other, non drug related things, the rooms and programs focus on one thing and one thing only

It really is just a form of maintainence without drugs. That's what annoys me; one can be heavily addicted to NA, but it's a "healthy" addiction in the eyes of 12 steppers and people who are ignorant about drugs. Since drug use is so stigmatized, it's automatically a bad thing to many people. This stifles actual attempts at recovery and addressing the mindset. In rehabs, they will always encourage you go to meetings, especially when you first come out. The suggestion they say is "90 meetings in 90 days." Doing something for 90 days seems like it'd be an addiction in and of itself. Surely anyone in a program or in "recovery" would say 90 straight days of heroin or cocaine use is a sign you are addicted; yet they promote the very same concept for meetings. Furthermore, people will freak out if they don't get their meeting dosage. Some, if they don't go to their daily meeting, act as if not doing so is going to send them spiraling back into a horrific relapse that will end when they hit a new bottom.

To me NA and AA don't promote any kind of progress in a program. They seemed focused heavily on members staying committed to said program to the point where they promote life long membership. I personally think any kind of program should promote some sort of change at some point. NA expects you to rid your life of drugs, however filling that void with NA is fine to them. I think a successful program should have some sort of end to it. Now if you intend to go into a maintainence program, I think it is different. As long as you are functional, I think maintainence should last as long as the individual using it wants. If someone wants to use heroin, methadone, suboxone, anything to maintain for the rest of their life and they are content with it, that should be their prerogative. If they expect to be off of everything, or not have to be dependent on something, I think a program should promote an eventual end. NA becomes a lifelong committment for many

Finally, I think too much emphasis is placed on avoiding people, places, and things. I consider a true measure of success to be the ability to confront people, places, and things head on without resorting back to your old ways. Avoiding or changing such things I feel is a copout and a way of running from your problems. Now if you have someone who say got you in trouble, or snitched, or is just a bad influence, that's different. Likewise, if you want to avoid copping on the block, and want to stay clear of that whole scene and the risks involved, it's different. I wouldn't advocate going down to the hood where you used to score just to prove a point. Many who try to avoid people places and things, however, take it to a whole new level, avoiding anyone who does drugs, anywhere drugs might be, etc. If I am trying to get clean off heroin, why should I avoid a party with people I consider friends because there will be drinking and weed smoking there? I personally like to confront my problems. If I have a clean period, I will still hang out with people whether they are using or not. If I get tempted into using, it's my problem, and it is my willpower which dictates whether or not I'll use. I have been at many parties with people smoking and drinking, or in crowds of smokers, and have abstained for various reasons, namely the possibility of a pending drug test. This is another factor which I find to be life consuming about 12 step programs. Instead of associating with people you are friends with, and possibly with people you have known for a good period of time, it promotes making new friends and associates within the program. The idea of abandoning people I consider friends because they choose to use drugs while I wish to abstain is absurd to me. So long as someone does not push it down your throat, I think success relies in maintaining past relationships, or amending them to work with your desire to abstain. I feel as if drugs really play that big a role, people places and things will avoid YOU if the relationship is solely related to drugs; people heavy into drugs and whose life is consumed and centered around drugs most likely will just lose interest in you if you choose to abstain. As I said previously, no one who travels into the city for the sole purpose of copping dope is going to hit the block with any intention otherwise, so avoiding a place in that example is really more common sense than anything
 
Firstly, I would strip all religion out of it. It's mostly christianity anyway. Doing so would put the healthy burden of recovery on the user not something that is intangible. God is not going to come down and pull the needle out of your arm. (and if you're at that point already you would be pissed if that happened8o:!).

I agree that someone who isnt using and thinking about drugs constantly is worse than someone who is using but maintains a functioning life. However some people simply cant do that which is where dogma comes in. The simple fact of the matter is that you cant teach someone willpower, the best you can do is distract them for long enough for them to think about something else. So I guess my program would involve doing a very wide range of activities. I believe that non-addicts have had their whole lives to find things that interest them and make them happy, where as addicts found what ''worked'' for them and stopped looking.

One thing that I dont really like about meetings is that it puts people together who only have one thing in common. Sure I am a drug addict, but just as a I would shun the kid who would say "You smoke to? we should totally hang out!" I feel the same way about recovering addicts. I personally believe one on one therapy is considerably more effective than group therapy. Especially therapy with a person who is trained to do so.

Im getting tired so I'll close. Not everyone has willpower and some people are hopelessly psychologically addicted to the point where they simply cant conquer their addiction and only through a deep understanding of themselves and what makes them truly happy can one recover.
 
Top