• Psychedelic Drugs Welcome Guest
    View threads about
    Posting RulesBluelight Rules
    PD's Best Threads Index
    Social ThreadSupport Bluelight
    Psychedelic Beginner's FAQ
  • PD Moderators: Esperighanto | JackARoe |

mushrooms vs LSD... thoughts

insanit_e

Bluelighter
Joined
Jun 14, 2005
Messages
486
Location
Australia
Apologies in advance if this thread has been done before, or if it is not appropriate to the guidelines for whatever reason. But I have been thinking about this a lot in the last week, since my first proper mushroom trip (that worked), and I feel like putting it down on words, and hearing what other people's opinions on this are.

I know that no two drugs, especially psychedelics, are really "comparable" in that is is like comparing apples and oranges. But I was actually struck by how similar mushrooms felt to acid, more than i had expected it would anyway, but it was also the many differences that made the trip quite difficult for me.

I have taken acid at least 30 times in my life I would say, maybe more, and I have certainly had difficult trips, but nothing that I would ever call bad. This is because I find acid to be extremely analytical- my brain thinks through things at a million miles an hour but in an extremely mathematical, conclusional kind of way- and because of this, any difficulty that i come accross, whether it be an emotional, spiritual, material issue etc., i can "think" my way through it, and eventually come to conclusions about it and work through it. I feel like despite how strong the trip may be, I always feel some level of control over the trip, and over my mindset, and I have the trust that I can get through any negativity.

I had a lot of confidence that if I could handle acid I could handle mushrooms, but they really took me by suprise. The main thing i found was that, compared to acid- mushrooms are much more "feely", whereas acid is much more "thinky"- because of that, being both an analytical and emotional sort of person, with acid I can "think" my way through all my issues, whereas with mushrooms it was my very emotions that were telling me what was going on with myself- uncontrollable emotions. I felt as though I really had no control at all over the trip or over my emotions, and they were not necessarily feelings i could think through logically. I feel as though the traditional "set and setting" formula doesn't necessarily mean anything for the mushroom trip, as a bad trip could just spring out of nowhere- a subconsious negative emotion that you were not aware of prior to tripping.

I also found mushrooms to be much more visual, but not as focussed, bright and patterned as acid- just everything constantly moving in a really overwhelming sort of way.

I can totally see now why mushrooms have the potential to be both absolutely incredibly amazing, and also abolutely terrifyingly terrible, i think more so than acid. I personally much prefer acid I think, it's style of learning sits better with me, but I think mushrooms is the kind of thing i would do when really really really wanting/ready to spiritually shake myself up.

What do others think about this comparison, and do you have any other ideas as to their main differences?
 
Set and setting is just as important with mushrooms.

They both can elicit powerful/meaningful experience.
They both can be completely silly at times.
They both can be scary at times.

I feel mushrooms has more of a body trip component probably due to the various alkaloids you are ingesting.

LSD is more enjoyable for me at a concert/rave
Mushrooms I thoroughly enjoy camping and stuff.
 
Both are comparable yet not really. Acid makes me analytical as hell and mushrooms make me contemplative and poetic, with bursts of laughter and madness. I personally enjoy them both very much and having to choose just one would make me a very SAAAAD panda.
 
although this may have been posted a fair few times, this is the first time i have read it :P

i prefer mushrooms over lsd... both good substances if taken correctly, but im not much of an intense tripper.
 
I pick and choose and change my mind every 6 months over which one I like better, mushrooms are very emotional for me, make me cry and come to terms with hidden issues, acid is often a laugh fest, hysterical fits of dumb cyclic joking all based on a punchline that had more to do with a facial expression than the words themself... inexplicable HILARITY... mushrooms are like "oh my lord... i'm incapacitated by beauty!" LSD gets me more clever, more into detail, less... loaded. lol
 
I've tripped on cid thrice now, and loved it each time - however I still prefer shrooms. Don't really feel ready to compare them yet seeing as I've not gone beyond one tab and not tripped in the day (it's always been at night, when I've been awake for like 12+ hours already). I get the impression that if I dropped 3 tabs at 7 am on a sunny day I'd have an absolute blast!

One thing I have noticed, LSD increases my music appreciation, particularly of genres of music I'm not used to/don't normally like, substantially more than any other drug which is saying something as both shrooms and 2c-b have both facilitated entirely mind blowing music experiences in the past. As an example, I'm not normally into raps but hearing Wax Tailor 'Walk the Line' on acid was epic beyond articulation. :D
 
Mushrooms just give me nasty mood swings with very few visuals. LSD on the other hand, an experience where I feel very in control of my emotions, and epic visuals to boot.
 
For me Mushrooms are "realler" where acid is more colourful/farout
Mushrooms do get me more intouch with self where L just makes me melt FACE...
I cant say which i prefer id have to say L i droped 1 tab yesterday and i melted all overthe place it was nice but a little overwhelming and To farout at times...SO longstory short... L is more visual where shrooms are more emotional
 
I've experienced intense visuals on shrooms. They tend to be more vivid, and often shocking. Once I was walking along a rocky beach and saw tangled bodies amongst the rocks. Acid tends to be more flashes of color and distortions in spacial awareness and such for me. Also, what other people have mentioned about linear vs emotional thinking rings true. I think of acid as more "tripping out" and shrooms as "tripping in". I consider acid to be a good psychedelic baseline, and sometimes ingest a good hour before taking shrooms for an intense inward journey.
 
I have always found mushrooms to be much more ego dissolving. I use mushrooms for more spiritual guidance. Acid can be very spiritual but its way of teaching is very edgy for me at times, where mushrooms are very straightforward. I feel mushrooms are underrated. If you are looking for spirtual guidance/enlightenment I reccomend a high dose psilocybin trip. Sometimes trips just take time to be resolved in the mind.
 
"my brain thinks through things at a million miles an hour but in an extremely mathematical, conclusional kind of way- and because of this, any difficulty that i come accross, whether it be an emotional, spiritual, material issue etc., i can "think" my way through it, and eventually come to conclusions about it and work through it. "

This is how I felt on mushrooms :) I never tried acid though
 
Top