This is a very simplistic view and is in some ways false.
well lets meet at our local lab armed with our papers and post to the journal of heptic function our arguments and allow our peers at high noon to decide who has the better argument.
of course its simplistic. its the fricken internet.
That said a response to a simplistic argument does not justify a banal insult especially when you've post absolutely no evidence to support your claims.
Bitters are PROVEN to stimulate the liver to produce more bile. Bile is how the liver discharges toxins as well as digestive enzymes.
Bile is produced primarily for digestion. If you ate more bitters (and I cannot see any evidence from you to support your claim) it does not neccesarily support the causal relationship that you will discharge more toxins.
I can drink lots of water and that will certainly simulate the the production of more urine but my body won't, necessarily discharge more "toxins".
Instead the body will often change the balance of its discharge subject to what it has too much of vs not enough of.
What about anti-oxidants? They do more than nourish your body. They are not just building blocks. They negate free radicals.
as far I've read there is no hard and fast rule that artificially produced anti-oxidants result in a healthier person. If you combined all of the studies on vitamin c (which is what someone did) and statistically analysed all of them they still don't give result that supports the widely argued contention that vitamin c will cure you from the cold or make you more healthier. In fact I would argue that most supplements are pointless unless you are suffering a major deficiency. Hence why i don't waste my money on supplements. I would rather buy a nice juicy salmon or trout instead. far better for my health.
Much that I have read is that vitamins are basically useless without the thousands of other compounds that (un-analysed) are found in fruits and vegetables. that it is the combination of vitamins and polyphenols in those foods that create the proven healthy benefit of eating good foods.
Granted you body needs vitamin but eating more vitamin then it needs does not make you healthier, at least no medical research i've read supports (feel free to post your thousands of respected peer reviewed articles). Sure you can read claims on hokey pokey health food sites but give me the double blind any day of the week over a large sample sizes.
Glutathione.....you need certain nutrition to make the stuff that helps you detox. This isnt just for the bodies building blocks, but certain molecules are needed for detox.
I never disagreed that your body needs things to function. Your liver needs all sorts of things to make its enzymes, and bile so it can remove excessive build up of various substances. But your argument is that lots of something will make the liver or kidneys discharge more toxins.
there is just no evidence for that claim (unless you want to post otherwise).
What about chelation? Did you know there are natural chelating elements in foods? Chelation therapy is used to remove heavy metals. Mild chelation occurs when you introduce chelating agents from other source as well, including trace amounts of chelating elements from foods.
ok dude, if i had heavy metals in my body at levels high enough to cause problems then sure there are many therapies to use. For example my body at this moment in time has thousands of rogue cancerous cells. but you know what my immune system is doing? Its moping them up when the cell's inbuilt suicide mechanism doesn't work.
But does that mean i should have chemo? no of course not. can i eat natural substances that are irradiated, sure I can. Will it kill some canceroures cells. Sure. but ultimately the aim is to provide a greater benefit to the harm being done. Now as far as I know 'chelation' is not a substance required for the functioning of a human. If we had a diet rich in toxic metals then fair enough i'm sure our bodies would have found a way to use chelation.
If you want to talk about a proven successful way of improving your health and that is a massively, calorie, restrictive diet.
I actually went to college for nutrition. There is a lot more to this stuff than some people realize.
I went to Universities and would sit on lectures but that doesn't make me right n or does it win me arguments on the internet.