AlsoTapered
Bluelighter
Loading…
www.mohfw.gov.in
Their is a lot of data out there. Above is the Indian Ministry of Health figures. The main reason I chose it is that it's an index paper i.e. it cites and is cited by a huge number of academic papers so if you put it into a search engine, it will bring up hundreds of relevant papers.
In a nation of 1.4 billion, the death of 533,458 isn't a large percentage but it's still a tragedy. but that over 44 million people required in-patient care is more interesting. That's putting a great strain on the system of medical care.
A friend of mine developed pneumonia, was taken to hospital and ended up dying on a gurney in a hospital corridor. The reason was simply that all of the critical care and respiratory ward beds were full. Obviously not all those beds were COVID victims but it significantly increased the pressure on one specific field of medicine. Their is no value in putting someone suffering respiratory distress onto a general ward, especially if they can then infect others who are already ill.
I am not suggesting that my single example is of any statistical value, but I know that health authorities sought to 'flatten the curve' i.e. to avoid a situation in which figures spike thus overwhelming the medical system. His name wouldn't be on any statistic but I suggest that indirectly COVID was the likely cause of his death.
So I assert that the Indian figures that state that COVID was the cause of death it merely a floor value. Indian people living in remote regions often had no access to appropriate medical care and in the case of deaths, the death certificate wouldn't mention COVID. Even testing wasn't widely available for the first year.
The WHO figures estimate that COVID was the direct cause of death of 4.7 million Indians. Some sources provide higher figures but the WHO does detail exactly how they calculated the estimate. But again, they point to those values representing a floor i.e. when a comorbidity was involved, they didn't include it in their figures.
What I found ironic was that I was struck down by hypokalemia, rushed to hospital and placed in a neurology ward (since general paralysis was the cardinal symptom) on the same day as my friend. Once diagnosed, essentially any general ward could have treated my condition equally well, it required no specialist equipment
Finally I would like to address the point that India is a huge nation and COVID did not affect each state in the same way. Some states had recorded cases two orders of magnitude higher than some other states. But in India, it's just not possible to evacuate someone with severe COVID symptoms to another state to reduce the load on the local medical system.
But I invite people to read the WHO data. It only details figures up to July 2022 (because proper data collection and analysis is a slow process if you seek a usable and as practically accurate figure possible)..
India Situation Report
By all means fell free to disagree with any or all of what I say and interrogate any fact I assert. I didn't simply believe one data point nor mistake deaths directly attributed to COVID with deaths in which COVID can be considered as being a significant factor. It was proportionally elderly people who died and comorbidities would likely be the rule rather than the exception. Maybe 4.7 million still isn't a huge percentage, it's only one in three hundred people on average. But as stated, the deviation from that average was large.
Last edited: