This is a question, not rhetorical. Do you think that someone who has had a problem with one drug can only make a recovery from addiction to that drug by becoming teetotal? Is it really all or nothing once addiction has been reached?
I don't know, I have never really been through the process. But everything I know about the human brain and behavior suggests that it should be possible for us to separate one altered state from another. I can't see why a coke addict who is fully recovered and clean for a few years couldn't take salvia for instance, particularly if it is search of something other than "getting out of it".
Obviously it depends on the person, the stage of recovery and what the goals are. My answer to this question would be that unless the person has been clean for a while, and wants to use psychedelics for a different purpose than recreation then no. But if they have and they ask then think about it.
In my opinion, there is to much focus on the class of drugs in this thread and not enough in the nature of addiction in general. When it comes to addiction in my studies (I am a social worker and a Graduate Student in an Social Work program with an addiction treatment focus) as well as my personal experience as an addict (who is now in recovery) it doesn't matter if a drug is a psychedelic, opiate, stimulant etc etc I will abuse it. True, psychedelics do not have the abuse potential that some other drugs do but the tolerance issue comes into play with that. Many of us know the "acid causality". Its pretty hard to get high on something like LSD several days in a row, but believe me people try. Furthermore, drugs like Cannabis, Dissociatives and even MDMA can and have been abused with more frequency over the past 2 decades. Hell, PCP was very popular for quite some time. When I was using psychedelics a lot, I did them excessively, just like any other drug.
The class of drugs never mattered to me, if I could abuse it I would. Sure, I had my favorites, but I still would abuse anything I could get my hands on. If I did start using again, the story would be the same. This isn't going away, I'd guess the only hope would be genetic manipulation maybe. I cannot use any mind or mood altering substance without placing myself at risk. I have 15 years of personal experience with this.
But I am getting off topic, addicts tend to very seldom use drugs recreationally. They are seeking to fill a void, cover emotions, forget their issues, feel empowered, control a situation, ignore a situation etc etc. Addicts are of course extremely prone to relapse.. Putting oneself in an altered state when in recovery can cause several things. It can cause guilt about "screwing up" which leads to a "fuck it" which leads back to a drug of choice. It can cause someone to think "well I handled this just fine so I can handle that". Of course Psychedelics can cause the individual to focus on one's pass and often addicts feel guilt over that. It is nowhere guaranteed that the experience will be beneficial.
Just an example of what could happen: Your friend ends up having a bad trip, it happens. He feels so overwhelmed with anxiety he seeks out a sure-fire way to rid himself of that anxiety. Booze. The next day he drinks again. And same thing the next day. He gets drunk, seeks out coke and its back on. That's not all though, he ends up going back out for another two years or so and ends up using dope.
You might think that couldn't happen but it could. Like I said, Psychedelics in some ways lead to my opiate abuse. I used them for the comedowns initially and it just increased from there. It might sound extreme, but its a risk that isn't worth taking.
Now, there is a difference between addiction and abuse. 99.9 percent of addicts will not be able to use any substance without eventually causing themselves problems. Abusers who are not addicts tend to outgrow their issues. The fact that your friend had multiple dependencies adds to the issue. Furthermore, only he knows how bad his use was. He could be under-reporting it. He could still be in a bit of denial. There are so many factors at play that it simply isn't worth he risk, no matter your intentions. Again, I urge you to think about you having to ask if this is a good idea. Good ideas usually do not need second thoughts.
phactor: My friend is someone I know extremely intimately, I know him in my own bones. I can feel nearly full certainty that he will stick to a life free of booze and coke. Watching his detox and recovery has given me new hope in the possibility of recovery from addiction, and even in the human ability to break patterns. So yes I have the right to judge his recovery. And it's a good thing.
First of all, you can feel nearly full certainty all you want but really all most addicts have is today. You will see people with 5, 10, 15, 20, 30 years relapse all the time. It happens. Nobody can guarantee anything when it comes to recovery. Especially, if they have people offering them drugs. I know for me that even though I try to avoid situations where drugs and alcohol are present, I do sometimes happen to come across them. Its still hard to ignore it. I still sometimes feel bad for myself when I pass a bar I used to go to. Its just the nature of the disease. We are addicts, we like to use. Problem is that when we use we suffer extreme consequences because most of us literally cannot stop without tremendous effort.
This is a harm reduction board, I argue that doing anything to jeopardize an individuals recovery does not match this boards intended purpose. Also, you really do not have any right to judge his recovery. Its great its an inspiration to you and all, but that doesn't matter. His recovery is his alone and isn't something to be trifled with. I am sure you can find other people to trip with. Again, no offense intended.
This is a very narrow-minded view of "recovery" that's parroted by AA and treatment centers. The long-term goals for anyone with past problems are going to be different. Some might subscribe to the teetotaler idea, while some might want to live a happy life instead.
I am happiest and most spiritually fit when I am totally clean. People can live a happy life clean. In fact, most of the people with addiction issues that I know are happy have stayed clean. I know very few addicts who have started using again who are happy. Even if they are "just drinking" or something like that.
Last edited: