• Philosophy and Spirituality
    Welcome Guest
    Posting Rules Bluelight Rules
    Threads of Note Socialize
  • P&S Moderators: JackARoe | Cheshire_Kat

Freemasonry ... cult or a boys club?

Aegslenaarthes

Bluelighter
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
60
Location
Barnyard Valley, UK
I've been interested in Freemasonry for a very long time. Unfortunately there's a lot of obscure/exaggerated claims out there which I could never be certain are true or false. I often think the values on the surface are a good idea, and being an agnostic I'm not too fussed about saying that I believe in a supreme being. Given the vague identification within Masonic entry requirements of 'supreme being' that could very easily be myself, this is something I know to exist (at least in this dimension) and therefore believe. My mind is open always when it comes to philosophy, but not so to McPhilosophy (e.g. organised religion) - I just think that this is far too idealist and a well formed life philosophy is based more on personal discovery, interpretation in my opinion and observation, rather than just teachings of morals and values. As for fundamentalism, I'm not even going to go there.

I like the values that Freemasonry advertises on the surface, and have a very good opportunity to join them and get to know 'the craft' coming my way quite soon. That's never been a problem for me, until now.

As above, I'm an agnostic. This begins to open up a problem for me that verges on the brink of a spiritual dilemma, for it is often said that the rites of initiation in many degrees of Freemasonry involve submitting ones self to curses where evil spirits are both attracted to pour in the body, or certain vital parts of the body. While it is said that curses can be renounced, I am quite put off by doing so in the name of "Jesus Christ" and wonder if this is a result of things like opposition from the Catholic church and other religious groups.

I have always been open to the idea of spirituality, or what I believe to be my interpretation of spirituality. There is just not enough evidence available in this reality for us to truly know. While there is absence of evidence of spirituality and/or a supreme being (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, I welcome it), I cannot take this as evidence of absence and so would not like to be taking on any curses anytime soon since if I am open to the idea of spirits I must accept that there are those good and bad spirits as well.

This is a legitimate concern to more people that I had once thought. I have had atheists sit there and tell me about their understanding of the universe, quantum phsyics etc etc and explain to me how there is no god, or at least a certain interpretation of god, and no spirits, just this and nothing else. That said, plenty of people amongst them have also told me to keep a permanently wide berth from ever having anything to do with the Ouija board. Is this just hypocrisy? Or is there really a fear that the body or the mind cannot let go, even after accepting the perfectly understandable reasons to be an atheist or nontheistic by nature?

I have always wanted to talk to a medium, get a reading. There are a lot of phenomena surrounding me that warrant such an investigation. I have been interested in Ouija board, because I just want to know something beyond. I get a lot of funny looks when I say this, and profound serious warnings of abandon hope all ye who enter here.

I cannot live from the spook stories of others because of the lack of ever experiencing anything I can reasonably interpret as supernatural myself, aside from little things which put curiosity firmly in mind. I am very mindful of how easy it is to succumb to confirmation bias and a misinterpretation of co-incidences, especially when such a misinterpretation occurs in others through their stories to me. I also have a very good knack of rooting out cold readers, so I am sceptical about seeing a medium too although I have never found the right kind of place or people to go and do this.

Back to my original musing, if Freemasonry is not cursed and I'm not going to attract misery and suffering on myself, family and friends then I would be very interested in joining to personally develop myself, get to know people and live a more charitable life, maybe make some new friends as this year marks a huge change for me. Yes I may be breaking the law at times and therefore bringing myself into disrepute (contrary to membership requirements) but there's just certain shit in this life you don't go around telling people. I'm not a bondsman either but that's debatable since I'm currently on Jobseeker's Allowance.

However, if there is something untoward, or there would be something I could be deeply missing I would like to know now rather than regret it later. I cannot weigh this one up so the scales are on the table for you, feel free to add the missing pieces to the balance 8(
 
You're overanalysing and this is causing your anxiety. If you really agree with the values, you will enjoy it. :)

Welcome to bluelight.
 
Listen to how you feel about it, not what you think. The external information about Freemasonry is useless, completely irrelevant; go and experience it first-hand =)
 
My grandpa is a Freemason and it's his main social outlet.

This is the extent of what I know about it: You can't become a Freemason if you're an atheist, they fucking hate atheists. You have to be of some religion and of good social/economic standing to be accepted (they use white/black dice from members to decide).

Basically it's a Gnostic-luciferean ethos with a strong emphasis on ritual. It was originally formed to try and free humanity from Catholic rule (of which it did a great job). They worship "light"; aka: gnosis, the mind, knowledge, Lucifer.

And yes it helps you in your career.
 
Listen to how you feel about it, not what you think. The external information about Freemasonry is useless, completely irrelevant; go and experience it first-hand =)

Just replace the F word with drugs in that quote and you have a certain other philosophy of mine. One I very nearly went my entire life without discovering, ironically out of some self questioning inertia like this. What often makes me overanalyse though are the little things, like what turns an atheist into a godfearing person in times of absolute crisis or imminent mortality, or even simply fear about either of the two.

These for me provide at least some suggestion of the spiritual, and would not like to shake my soul loose if ever there was one in a ritual room thanks to a bunch of old men I barely know.

You're both spot on, but overthinking is like a fulltime job for me. Perhaps some ways of coping with this is probably more what I'm reaching out for.
 
Basically it's a Gnostic-luciferean ethos with a strong emphasis on ritual. It was originally formed to try and free humanity from Catholic rule (of which it did a great job). They worship "light"; aka: gnosis, the mind, knowledge, Lucifer. .

If gnosis is such a virtue which rejects catholic rule, why would an atheist be such a problem? That seems like a bit of a contradiction in principles to me. My interpretation of a supreme being is like Schroedinger's cat for me and everchanging on an almost daily basis. I will not have any reservations about telling them what they need to hear so that I might get the opportunity to learn more, which might be enlightening I could never know until I try it.

There is a good chance that I might be accepted through forthcoming university enrolment where, if I don't fuck things up, there are very good career prospects for me. I think this would take care of my social standing, economic well that may come later.
 
Well you may not know but the Freemasons are the "underground" version of the Knights Templar. When Philip IV along with the Catholics decided to wipe them out (because they had so much money/power as they were the original 'bankers' of Europe) in 1307, the Templars moved their operations to England and went underground (hence all the old Templar chapels throughout England). Hence for a long time their aim was to foster the emancipation of Europe from Catholic rule and persecution of the Protestants.

ALSO this is the reason why Catholics were for so long BANNED from being Freemasons, this is all different now since a modern Pope (forget which one) decreed it was OK.

I'm not exactly sure why they hate Atheists, but they do. I guess being a Gnostic organiztion it's built around theistic principles. Either way I know for a fact that if you're Atheist you have no chance of being accepted, you're "black-balled" instantly. I'm not sure what they would think of your "Schroedinger's cat" beliefs, lol.

And yes I've heard that university is a great way of getting involved.
 
Seems like a very well organized and highly reputable frat to me.
Obviously it can have goals and values and ideals. Even frats do charity and advocacy.
But it's still a club which emphasizes secrecy, elitism, and separation. Which is why I disagree with their ideology
If affluence or standing is a requisite for membership, I want nothing to do with that organization.
Same goes for any group who hides what they do.
 
I'm not sure what they would think of your "Schroedinger's cat" beliefs, lol.

it comes down to what i would tell them. my view is that a supreme being (still open to interpretation as to what comprises 'supreme being') both exists and does not exist, since there is not enough evidence to support the existential reality of a supreme being; we can't prove or disprove the presence or absence of something we can neither clearly define nor understand. i wouldn't however come out with this, i would just accept that a supreme being is what i believe in - if this is not discussed in freemasonry as they so claim then i can't see that being much of a problem

But it's still a club which emphasizes secrecy, elitism, and separation. Which is why I disagree with their ideology
If affluence or standing is a requisite for membership, I want nothing to do with that organization.
Same goes for any group who hides what they do.

i would be inclined to agree on principle but i would not mind walking with elitists, so long as i could stay true to myself and my friends/family. if elitism was the primary focus and required of me to partake in freemasonry i would probably say my thank yous and leave. if it was something as simple as standing well, that's someone else's elitism and not mine. it's a kind of tourism for me, getting to know how people in positions of power think and like to live their lives, which would be just as rewarding as pursuing the aforementioned values and ideals.

it's the goals part which is a dubious talking point i think - and my ever unanswerable questions about the unknown. quite a big leap of faith to make if you're one who gets concerned about this sort of thing
 
I don't have any issue with being elite itself. If you've acquired a position of power and influence through your works and ideas, you deserve that position and the power that comes with it. The problem I have is in the exclusion of those who have not achieved these things.
I think the purpose of any institution dedicated to enlightenment ought to be to bring the rest of the world out of the darkness, not keep them out of the loop with a shadowy curtain.
 
i would be inclined to agree on principle but i would not mind walking with elitists, so long as i could stay true to myself and my friends/family. if elitism was the primary focus and required of me to partake in freemasonry i would probably say my thank yous and leave. if it was something as simple as standing well, that's someone else's elitism and not mine. it's a kind of tourism for me, getting to know how people in positions of power think and like to live their lives, which would be just as rewarding as pursuing the aforementioned values and ideals.

it's the goals part which is a dubious talking point i think - and my ever unanswerable questions about the unknown. quite a big leap of faith to make if you're one who gets concerned about this sort of thing

In my rummaging on the topic, what I have concluded with, is that Freemasonry is here to help sustain the underlying structure of society by volunteering your best personal attributes, nothing too dramatic about it.
 
In my rummaging on the topic, what I have concluded with, is that Freemasonry is here to help sustain the underlying structure of society by volunteering your best personal attributes, nothing too dramatic about it.

i wonder if any masons lurk the ranks of this forum, doesn't seem likely because of the requirement to be law abiding, but not completely unfeasible. either way it would be interesting to hear what they think about all of this
 
Seems like a very well organized and highly reputable frat to me.
Obviously it can have goals and values and ideals. Even frats do charity and advocacy.
But it's still a club which emphasizes secrecy, elitism, and separation. Which is why I disagree with their ideology
If affluence or standing is a requisite for membership, I want nothing to do with that organization.
Same goes for any group who hides what they do.


-there's not as much secrecy as the hype suggests
-affluence/status holds no weight in membership applicability directly
 
Top