Aros2k, thanks for the response - it always helps to know what our members want (at least those willing to speak up, so thank you). We like to keep our members wants and needs in mind when we try to go forward, but your response does reflect the isolationist view some members have with their forums.
You're right in that the 'traveling thread' concept as a tool to get people to spread their wings to other forums won't really ...errr...fly. Someone's not necessarily going to follow a thread simple because it was moved, and many will be like yourself and simply continue on with topics that remain in their 'home forum'. Would moving such a thread cause people to leave the site? Possibly. That's not what we'd be intending, but it is possible. Would some people follow it and participate more in other areas, either learning more or perhaps teaching others more? Possibly, and that was the intent with what you captured in your quote.
Both outcomes are possible, and I'd be willing to bet that a bit of both would occur. Not ideal, but the status quo isn't exactly what we want as a site, either. For some people, BL is only a few select forums, and the difference between logging into BL for those few vs logging into a separate site, on a separate server....at least for those people....is nil. So from the member perspective, there is the strong chance that such actions would degrade the enjoyment of 'their site'.
Taking a step back to the perspective of site management, there's a different perspective, one that has to be balanced with the 'member wants and needs'. Part of our intent is that BL is a very strong community with a drug education and HR theme - we're not just a reference book on a shelf, we are a mixture of diverse people and experiences, all of which sum together to make us much more than a separate site, on a separate server. Part of our intent is to leverage that diversity and depth of experience into building upon our strength for an even better site.
Yes, the 'dragging' of members to other forums is part of it, part of a harkening back to the feel of when we were a smaller community (similar to what some feel with the site when they ignore the other 45 forums), and trying to get that feel with a much larger population. But to a large degree, that 'wish' is unrealistic. We ARE a large population, and to think everyone would visit all, or even more than an handful of, forums is a bit naive. But we can try, and we're open to suggestions on how we can get people to willingly explore what else is on the site, what other people are on here, for whatever the individual's interests might be.
But what wasn't captured in your quote is the other part of the intent, the part of building our community database, or the collection of experiences of our widespread membership. The site began with a small community, relying on one another for information and building a database of realistic drug information and harm reduction as opposed to government propaganda or assuming individuals jumping into trouble on their own. We're a lot bigger now. A LOT bigger, and it only makes sense to use that bigger collection of minds and experiences to improve the information we have available to readers.
Some of that knowledge IS regional, like local laws and strains of whatever drug is floating around (the effects, the dangers, etc). But a lot of it isn't regional - a drug is a drug. Getting high on Heroin in the states is pretty close to what's in EU or AUS. Different grades, but people still shoot up, still purify, still need to know the danger signs of an overdose and what to do about it. These kinds of things, unfortunately, have gotten holed up in the corners of the site to where, for example, AUS and EADD each have their own awesome collection of GBL-GHB knowledge.....which is available to the members in that forum....but ought to be available to EVERYONE. And the information within them - if conflicting, ought to be hashed out; if agreeing, ought to be brought together to support one another. So that's another aspect of traveling threads - building the BEST collection of the information available on the site, generating awareness ACROSS multiple forums, making our main goal (HR, and also drug education) that much stronger of an offering to lurkers, media, and our members in general. Now, we need a better way of getting that information collected, corrected, and presented; but for now a traveling thread might be the best way anyone's come up with for accomplishing this. Still, we're always open to more ideas or suggestions. The one about 'leave it alone, I like it how it is' is good to know, but may not help us in trying to improve everything we're trying to address.....so we remain open for discussion on how to keep that 'homey feel' and still achieve the site goals. We're not (to quote a friend of mine) 'fucking rocket surgeons' and we realize we can't think of everything, so your (everyone's) thoughts and suggestions are wanted and appreciated.