Just finished watching it. Absolutely mind blowing. Definitely the most graphic thing I've ever seen. Incredibly disturbing horror, like nothing else. I have no idea how this film got past the censors.
The movie has a false opacity, and it almost gets away with it. But despite the adult themes and almost-getting-away-with-it opacity, it is very obvious that this film is targeted toward a young audience. The film has a serious problem: almost anyone can understand every theme. This means that the violence, Willam Dafoe, and even the false opacity are all marketing ploys that take up almost 100% of the film.
That sounds very clever but I don't think it reflects Von Trier's attitude towards his art at all. And I'm not sure that the film being universally accessible is such a bad thing, necessarily.
I think you're taking way too much of an academic approach to this film.
If you're open to feeling something and open to being connected to this film, rather than analyzing, I don't understand how numerous scenes didn't freak you out or move you in
some way at least a little bit.
The violence really didn't do much for me. Other people seemed pretty freaked out by it, but the film makers didn't build the characters enough to make the shock sequences much more than cardboard dinosaurs that jump out at the rollercoaster in a theme park.
If you really had no reaction to seeing that, then I don't know... that's pretty fucking weird. I mean I assume that it would freak you out in real life, which means that you're kind of blaze and disconnected from the film version of the event.. if you know what I mean... and then what's the point of watching movies if you're not going to let them engage you?
Why does every film need to follow the rules of narrative and flesh out characters enough so that we care about them each individually?
Horror is renowned for having under-developed characters.
That image (I'm pretty sure you know which one I mean) should shock you regardless of character development. But that doesn't mean it's just shock value cause personally I thought it fit into the context of the film perfectly.
4.5/5