[Reposted from a post I made on usenet:]
Noticed some big discrepancies...
Rolling Stone version: Josh and friend were at hotel alone. Josh freaked
out. Friend called some other friends to come to hotel and help. Josh was
put into friend's car. Friend ran into hotel to get belongings. Sheriff
came to handle noise complaint, but left after speaking to friend. Friend
came back out. Josh was in car spazzing out and hitting head against
dashboard. Friend called other friend, and drove Josh to other friend's
house. Friends notice Josh is dead, try to give CPR. Second friend runs
into house and puts on jeans, gets jeans to try putting on Josh. Friends
drove Josh to hospital.
Erowid version: Josh and friend were at unspecified location with other
people. Josh freaked out. Someone took Josh out to parking lot. Sheriff
visited the location for a noise complaint, but left because it had
settled down. At some point after sheriff left, Josh's friend went outside
and found Josh unconscious in the car in a strange position. Friend
realized Josh needed help, drove immediately to hospital. Josh was
unresponsive the whole way there. Friend believes Josh died en route.
Obviously, these two versions of the story do not match up on many crucial
details.
Shiney, could you clear things up a little? Also, did you ever
hear any details on the coroner's report? The local newspaper said the
coroners had ruled it an ecstasy overdose in their preliminary report, but
this may have changed after lab tests came back. Mr. Boal did not seem to
have bothered checking up on this crucial aspect of the story.
I spoke with the Erowid staff about their version of the story and they mentioned that their informant on the story did mention that they were at a hotel and that the friend called up some other people to come help deal with Josh. Theres still some disparity with the RS version though... according to RS, Josh ran naked out of the hotel and the people intercepted him in the parking lot, while the Erowid version has it that the friends came and carried him out to the parking lot. Then in the RS version, they all put Josh in the car and he was banging his head on the dashboard... while in the Erowid version, the original friend was still in the hotel dealing with the sheriff then came out and found Josh unconscious in the car. This information makes the two versions of the story above match a little better, but there's still some big disparities.