The Grand Budapest Hotel was mediocre and pretentious. Wes Anderson has this amazing artistic "stamp", like Tim Burton. But he hasn't got anything else. I'm getting really tired of the same shtick. Moonrise Kingdom was downright awful. As Anderson's career ages, like Burton (and Besson and others), his films are becoming more stamp and less substance. Personally, I'd rather flip the ratio and watch a raw film with real emotion.
Owen Wilson's character, in the Royal Tenenbaums, said something like: "We all know that General Custer died during the battle of Little Big Horn. What this film presupposes is: maybe he didn't?" Ironically, Anderson has become that character. What initially passed itself off as self-satire, has become shtick: Wes is extremely talented at making films appear to be more than they are, while simultaneously mocking pretentiousness in art. Problem is, that point can only be made once or twice before it falls apart. As time goes on it's becoming painfully obvious that the only real talent Mr. Anderson has is the precise thing he managed to build a career on by (playfully) ridiculing.
Anderson is not a great director. Neither is Tim Burton. They are very stylish directors, but it pretty much ends there.
Anderson's characters are often flat, for comedic effect. And, since the stamp to substance ratio continues to rise, they are becoming flatter and flatter. The characters in Moonrise Kingdom were like fucking robots. What children (or adults) speak like that? It's quirky, sure. But you can't build a respectable career on being quirky, can you?
The Grand Budapest Hotel comes across desperate.
It wants so badly to be a masterpiece.
Perhaps if Anderson expended more of his energy on building realistic, multi-dimensional and empathetic characters... if he bothered to write stories that were compelling without the quirks... if he focused a little less on Art Direction, editing and cinematography...
Maybe then he'd make a masterpiece.
But I don't think that's ever going to happen.
Favourite Anderson film (by far): Rushmore.