I've smoked mad sherm / dipped cigs the exact same way. Can still get it, but there are several drawbacks that make me prefer a salt form dissociative ultimately. It's possible to create HCl gas via dropwise addition of sulfuric acid onto a mound of pure NaCl soaked in muriatic acid (read: ~28% HCl) and have that piped off with PPE tubing and a claisen adapter after sifting through two cotton balls with about an inch of calcium chloride (damp rid) between them to dessicate that HCl gas on its way out the PPE and into your sherm juice. Crystals would form from this, which can be collected and cleaned up, etc. via filtration, ice-cold anhydrous acetone rinse, and/or 1- or 2-solvent recrystallization. Presto: angel dust from sherm.
But to answer your question, firstly I agree with tesseracts assessment, except, I feel like Ketamine is a better starting place than 2FDCK; however, 2FDCK has the advantage of being an RC and thus quasi-/semi-legal. Regardless, for my money, insufflating 3-HO-PCP is closest to smoking a dipper. Has a very similar headspace where your imagination can just run wild with epic, made-up storylines, and this takes on weird epic proportions. In my mind I'll be in the center of a global conspiracy sometimes. Other times I'll wax philosophic and my mind will wander down corridors of possibilities, both in my life and about the world/universe in general. I really value these experiences, much like my experiences with "love boat".
Worthwhile runner up to 3-HO-PCP would be 3-HO-PCE. Both of these compounds are fairly anxiolytic to me, despite the weird mental fugues at times. Conversely, I find 3-MeO-PCP and 3-MeO-PCE to be trippier and a bit less euphoric. Generally the eticyclidine (PCE) analogues are also trippier than their phencyclidine (PCP) counterparts, to me. Dissocs really do tend to affect different people much differently, so to some extent, this will take experimenting with things yourself. But hey, that's a fun endeavor to be sure; just use harm reduction techniques and stay informed. Best of luck!