The Heartbreaking Story Of A Harmless Deadhead Sentenced To Die In Prison

Status
Not open for further replies.

poledriver

Bluelighter
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
11,543
The Heartbreaking Story Of A Harmless Deadhead Sentenced To Die In Prison

Timothy Tyler was 25 when he was sentenced to die in prison.

Tyler, a Grateful Dead fan with no history of violence, got life without the possibility of parole for selling LSD to a police informant.

He'd never gone to prison before.

But a judge was forced to give him life because of two prior drug convictions — even though both those convictions resulted in probation.

At 45, Tyler has been in prison for more than 20 years and will likely spend the rest of his life there. He got the same life sentence as rapist and kidnapper Ariel Castro because of federal mandatory minimum sententence guidelines.

'Three strikes and you're out' no matter the charge

Congress enacted mandatory minimums — also known as "three strikes and you're out" laws — in response to the 1980s crack epidemic, and many states followed suit with similar laws.

These laws force judges to impose strict sentences based on the amount of drugs sold without regard for mitigating factors like drug addiction.

Tyler, for his part, had a history of psychosis and bipolar disorder. He did break the law, though.

He sold acid to friends for less than dollar a hit at Grateful Dead concerts, where he also sold fried dough, and he was arrested twice for drug offenses.

Then he got arrested a third time after selling larger quantities of the drug to a friend who turned out to be an informant.

"I wouldn't do it again," Tyler told Business Insider on the phone from the federal prison in Waymart, Penn. "I wouldn't have done it if I had known I could have gotten this kind of time."

To be clear, Tyler got busted for selling a lot of acid — 13,045 hits, according to a pre-sentence memorandum. But that memo doesn't make him and the guys he got busted with look like career criminals, either.

Tyler only netted about $3,000 from "a very loosely woven conspiracy" that involved selling acid to "friends, family and business acquaintances," according to the memo prepared by his probation officer.

He also made the government's job easier by pleading guilty.

"He explained to the probation officer that he is psychotic," the memo read, "and that his condition is complicated by his substance abuse problems."

Under the section of the memo titled "Victim Impact," it read, "There is no specifically identifiable victim."

A history of abuse

Tyler is not the only casualty of mandatory minimum sentences, but his case has always troubled Julie Stewart, the president and founder of Families Against Mandatory Minimums.

She's known about Tyler since he was sentenced in 1994.

"He was a kid. He was following the Grateful Dead. I'm not condoning it, but it was a pretty harmless lifestyle Timothy was leading," Stewart told me.

"It always seemed really absurd to me that this non-violent guy who was 24 years old, that the government could write off his life. Bingo. You're gone."

Tyler grew up in Terryville and Wolcott, Conn., with his single mother and his sister Carrie, who's 11 months younger and still considers him her best friend.

Their mother, Lura Morris, worked as a waitress and later went to the University of Connecticut and became a social worker.

The kids were happy when they were small, but life got difficult after Morris married a man named Sal when Tyler was about 7. Sal stayed home with the kids while Morris worked full-time.

Morris told me in an email message she noticed mania (hyper, impulsive behavior) and depression in both Timothy and his sister Carrie when they were kids. She found out later her then-husband terrorized her son.

"We had the worst stepfather in the world," Carrie Tyler-Stoafer told me. "He would just beat my brother, beat his head against the wall, and I would say leave him alone — and he would come after me."

He was his sister's protector, their mom told me. Tyler, who's now a vegetarian, was also a lover of animals who became very attached to "each, consecutive family pet," his mother said.

http://www.sfgate.com/technology/bu...king-Story-Of-A-Harmless-Deadhead-4693495.php
 
Well another life wasted becuase of bullshit laws. How about we, young people start getting involved into politics ? Don't you see we are surrounded by fiction and people who are creating this ficition are the ones who are meant to take care of us ? I feel so sorry for this guy becuase lets be honest he was selling one of the best substances known to man which because some old man in uncomfortable suits made it illegal 40 years ago.
 
^
LOL he pretty much was wasting his life already before he went to prison, and he was an adult and made his own choices and is where someone like himself should be. He's some guy's bitch now. He already had two arrests, and didn't learn his lesson that he gets caught and if someone wants to buy that much of a drug they are someone you should stay away from.

The article has a professional victim stance for this guy when it was his choice to sell drugs and get caught 3 times and he's someone who should have stayed away from using drugs since they are severly mentaly ill and psychotic. The article's writings sucks too but what else can you expect from the SF Gate and Erin Fuchs' writing?

SF Gate said:
During his early 20s, Tyler had several psychotic episodes. His mother told me that once he stood on a highway in Arizona naked, trying to build a dam, which landed him in a psych ward. He saw Jerry Garcia as God during his more psychotic moments. Tyler — who dated women before prison including his sister's best friend — also started having sex with other men in prison because he craved affection. This romance provides a mental escape from the four walls around him.
 
He's some guy's bitch now. He already had two arrests, and didn't learn his lesson that he gets caught and if someone wants to buy that much of a drug they are someone you should stay away from.

So he deserves the same sentence rapist and kidnapper Ariel Castro? For some drugs? You have to be kidding me. He'd never even gone to prison before. What a fucking joke of a law it is there. If he got caught with the same things here he wouldn't even do 8 years, probably not even 5.
 
That is an absolute joke. Poor guy. I really hope things change, as these draconian measures are not the answer to 'the problem' :(
 
Terrible and unjust situation.
Another life lost to the drug war.

^
LOL he pretty much was wasting his life already before he went to prison,

That is not your decision to make, really. He is free to spend his life the way he wants to spend it. If he values music, friendship, art, traveling, etc. I don't see how you could think he was wasting his life, but maybe you would prefer him to work for a bank and drink back his feelings each night. :| In any case, saying something like that without really knowing the situation seems overly judgmental.

he was an adult and made his own choices and is where someone like himself should be.

This is what conservative, angry, small-minded people often say in the face of a terribly unfair situation. He's an adult; he deserves it. But it doesn't address whether the law is far or not - it simply expresses distaste for the victim of an unfair law.

He's some guy's bitch now.
This is what people often say about those thrown in jail. It might not be true, but those who say it seem angry to me, as if someone else's bad luck pleases them greatly.


He already had two arrests, and didn't learn his lesson that he gets caught and if someone wants to buy that much of a drug they are someone you should stay away from.
Right, because people who buy small amounts of drugs are fine, but those who buy large amounts are terrible people, right?8(

The article has a professional victim stance for this guy when it was his choice to sell drugs and get caught 3 times
I didn't see anywhere that he chose to get caught.
It is easy to portray him as a victim because the law is clearly unfair.
Should a victimless "crime" be punished in the same way as kidnapping and rape?
That is what you are saying.
I doubt that you will find much support for your idea here, or most other places.

and he's someone who should have stayed away from using drugs since they are severly mentaly ill and psychotic.
This again avoids the whole issue of whether the law is just. While I agree with this statement, it is really tangential to the main question here.
 
The guy deserves to be in a mental ward or house arrest at the very worst. He obviously has issues, and rotting away in prison at the age of 25 is not going to help him resolve them. Unlike rapist and baby-killer Ariel Castro, this dude still has the capacity to do good in the world.
 
That is some fucked up shit, this dude definately messed up but giving him anywhere close to what he got is so wrong. He did sell a fuckload of acid but he made fuck all, I am not sure if this is because someone took advantage of his mental illness and they got him to do the dirty work while they made real money, or if this guy was just trying to dispense as much acid as cheaply as he possibly could, either way I don't think there is any argument that he is truly a bad person or any other argument that justifies anything close to that length of a prison term.

DrunkardsDream I strongly disagree with your views, why does he belong in jail exactly? What harm did he do to other people really? Perhaps some people had bad trips on his acid, but it was their choice to take it, if he was some dodgy fuck selling NBOME blotters I would have considerably less sympathy but he was selling legit acid from the information here. It really sounds to me like you percieve this guy as particularly stupid, and that stupidity (perhaps combined with mental illness) is enough to justify a lifelong prison term, that seems like an incredibly cruel and unjust point of view to hold. It is not a very practical point of view either, there are a LOT of stupid people in this world, the cost to house them all in jail indefinately for no infraction other than their stupidity would be immense and I doubt you would like to foot the bill personally.

You also claim he got caught selling drugs 3 times, he was convicted for drug offences 3 times but only states explicitly that the last time was for distribution, since he got probation the first few times I would guess that atleast one of those prior convictions was actually for possession, not sales, if it were for sales I would wager it was for an extremely small amount. The problem with the 3 strikes rule is you don't even have to be caught dealing the first two times, on the movie The House I Live In there is a guy doing life for 3 ounces of meth because he had two prior minor drug convictions, in these cases there isn't a person on earth who can argue that the punishment fits the crime, and even if you are indifferent to human rights (which you shouldn't be!) it should still piss you off as a taxpayer who funds these prisons.
 
Last edited:
there are a LOT of stupid people in this world, the cost to house them all in jail indefinately for no infraction other than their stupidity would be immense

A lot of them fall prey to snitches who are looking to reduce their own punishment or collect commission. This doesn't necessarily have to be for drug offences. Some cops in Chicago are in trouble now because they went around looking for crazy or gullible young people and torturing them until they signed confessions to open murders:

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/...e-illinois-torture-inquiry-torture-commission
 
^ Agree with Drug Mentor.
Drunkards Dream is still claiming that the guy in prison is dangerous. I have no idea why. Drug "crime" is victimless.
And the fact that he is 45 has nothing to do with anything. He has been in prison since he was 25. But even if he committed the "crime" now, it is still a victimless crime.
Do you get it, DD? Nobody was hurt. Nobody has to take LSD unless they choose to do so.
Not sure why this is even an issue to discuss...
 
To say he belongs in a ward or mental facility simply because he has mental illness, is incorrect, in my opinion, unless he is suffering acutely and needs that assistance, but it seems in the article is still suffers and needs help. But still, 20 year sentence is way too long for a nonviolent drug selling (lsd) crime. He seems like he knew that he could get caught, but not to such a high degree. Id say a much shorter sentence like 1-2 years would be better, or even better just probation, because hes seems aware of his actions. The three strikes law is faulty. Because this is such a low tier third strike...i mean life? No. If someone commits a horrid third strike then by all means yes. But this person does not deserve such a hefty sentence, simply because he had two prior charges.
 
He didn't do anything wrong.

He offered people what they wanted for a profit. Unless he were selling fraudulent items, or blatently ripping people off, there really is no case here. It's a victemless crime.
 
It matters to me what I believe. Yeah it's not worth arguing about, but I do believe that nobody anywhere in the world deserves life without parole for drug offences. Even if they get busted 5 times for the biggest drug manufacturing or distribution offences ever seen, I don't believe they deserve life in jail without the chance of ever getting parole, not for drugs. People who kill their kids or multiple children don't even get life without parole here. The US laws regarding drugs are fucked up.
 
I wish all these sorry ass informants get their karma handed to them 10000 fold. COkcsuckers. I couldnt live myself if id rat/set up someone no matter the situation. I dont have the words to express my hate towards rats, fucking scum of the earth they should be sent in a cockpit to the center of the sun.
 
What a sad story for the guy involved.
The sentence in no way matches the crime. He isn't a serial killer or didn't shoot a load of school kids,all he did was sell acid to someone who was asking for it.
Unlucky for him it was a member of the filth but to spend the rest of his life banged up is just plain wrong.
I've never understood the need for a 3 strikes and you are out law unless the crimes are particularly nasty.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top