film: Scent of a Woman

youarewhatyouis

Bluelighter

Joined

Jul 3, 2005

Messages

2,544

• Apr 23, 2007

• #1

great movie, or greatest movie?

I just rented it, and after not seeing it for about 5 years, it ranks up on my top 5 movies of all time list, easy.

 

alasdairm

Moderator: S&T

Staff member

Joined

Jul 22, 2002

Messages

66,907

• Apr 23, 2007

• #2

anything with pacino is great. anything with pacino massively overacting is sublime. so this is sublime.

i had a friend in london who saw this but couldn't recall the name. "last night i saw that movie... what was it called..." then he got it. "oh yeah... smell of a lady"



alasdair

 

cletus

Bluelight Crew

Joined

May 10, 2006

Messages

4,663

• Apr 23, 2007

• #3

youarewhatyouis said:

I just rented it, and after not seeing it for about 5 years, it ranks up on my top 5 movies of all time list, easy.

Click to expand...

Phew, that's a bold statement to make regarding what is undoubtedly not Pacino's best film.

Unless of course this at number 4 or 5 & Carlitos Way, Heat & Godfather II are also in your top 5. :D

 

youarewhatyouis

Bluelighter

Joined

Jul 3, 2005

Messages

2,544

• Apr 24, 2007

• #4

bold statement? Hoooah! heres the top six

god father 1 and 2, taxi driver, scent of a woman, fargo and pulp fiction.... in that order