MyDoorsAreOpen
Bluelight Crew
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2003
- Messages
- 8,549
I define hip as being in-the-know about new and cutting edge trends (in anything), and having the uncanny ability to tell the difference between new and fringy trends that will become big and influential, and ones that will always be marginal, and to adopt early those former ones before the masses do. I liken it to lesson number one of surfing, which is being able to jump on your board in anticipation of a wave that hasn't yet broken, at just the right moment.
I am a comfortable inhabitant of the fringes. But I am also comfortably unhip. I can't count the number of times someone has mistaken my wanderings in things lesser known for a desire to be seen as trendy. Usually this takes the form of someone taking a dig at me for not knowing something they think someone like me should have known, or gloating over something they know that I don't know. Worse, I've known people with the audacity to try and tell me, "I don't know why you're into that, be into this instead." Clearly they don't get the point. My wanderings and likings for things have nothing to do with their social caché, and I'm not telling you about my passion for them because I'm trying to one-up you or impress you. I like what speaks to me, and see no need to justify it on any external basis. I couldn't care less if anything that brings me joy is uncool, and will always be uncool.
Interestingly enough, this problem tends to come up for me when I accidentally stumble upon something I really like which happens to be an up and coming trend. Then I'm "supposed to" be into a whole lot of other things that people who are into that are too (not necessarily), and am "supposed to" lose interest in it when it peaks and declines in popularity (but what if I still enjoy it?)
I know there's no point in arguing about taste, as some famous dead Roman guy said. But what I'm after is, is there any real practical advantage to be had in pursuing hipness? Does one's quality of life truly stand to improve if one is always there ahead of the crowd. I'm not convinced it necessarily makes one either happier or more materially secure. I have a feeling hipness is one of those things that might have carried a real survival advantage in our hunter-gatherer past, and that the dangerously Schadenfreude-like joy of being savvy to something great before everyone else is just an evolutionary holdover that some people like to indulge, similar to why we enjoy sports or gossip.
Of course, any true hipster will probably just call "sour grapes" on me.
Any thoughts?
I am a comfortable inhabitant of the fringes. But I am also comfortably unhip. I can't count the number of times someone has mistaken my wanderings in things lesser known for a desire to be seen as trendy. Usually this takes the form of someone taking a dig at me for not knowing something they think someone like me should have known, or gloating over something they know that I don't know. Worse, I've known people with the audacity to try and tell me, "I don't know why you're into that, be into this instead." Clearly they don't get the point. My wanderings and likings for things have nothing to do with their social caché, and I'm not telling you about my passion for them because I'm trying to one-up you or impress you. I like what speaks to me, and see no need to justify it on any external basis. I couldn't care less if anything that brings me joy is uncool, and will always be uncool.
Interestingly enough, this problem tends to come up for me when I accidentally stumble upon something I really like which happens to be an up and coming trend. Then I'm "supposed to" be into a whole lot of other things that people who are into that are too (not necessarily), and am "supposed to" lose interest in it when it peaks and declines in popularity (but what if I still enjoy it?)
I know there's no point in arguing about taste, as some famous dead Roman guy said. But what I'm after is, is there any real practical advantage to be had in pursuing hipness? Does one's quality of life truly stand to improve if one is always there ahead of the crowd. I'm not convinced it necessarily makes one either happier or more materially secure. I have a feeling hipness is one of those things that might have carried a real survival advantage in our hunter-gatherer past, and that the dangerously Schadenfreude-like joy of being savvy to something great before everyone else is just an evolutionary holdover that some people like to indulge, similar to why we enjoy sports or gossip.
Of course, any true hipster will probably just call "sour grapes" on me.

Any thoughts?