Pink Floyd vs Led Zeppelin

[ninjadanslarbretabar]

vs

GO !

 

[ninjadanslarbretabar]

pink floyd for me thats for sure
it took me some time to appreciate Robert Plant voice
pink floyd is way more diversified, but they have the advantage of a longer carrier too

not sure which one was the more influential but Led Zeppelin had a rapid, direct influence on what was going on at the time

 

[Pander Bear]

another vote for floyd, especially if I shut my eyes and plug my ears if someone starts talking about their work after Dark side.

 

[Jamshyd]

Pink Floyd.

If for nothing else, then because they're slightly less unattractive than zeppelin in the pics you posted

 

[AmorRoark]

Man ninja, you sure are making us create a lot of polls recently.

I went with Pink Floyd, naturally.

 

[atri]

floyd
i can listen to dark side on repeat for weeks at a time in my car

 

[tribal girl]

Tough call but I'm gonna go with Led Zep.

 

[ninjadanslarbretabar]

haha Jamshyd that made me laugh

 

[Finder]

What is the deal with these arbitrary match-ups?

 

[Pander Bear]

the theme for this one is:

"bands you really loved in highschool that BA still loves at 30"

 

[ninjadanslarbretabar]

What is the deal with these arbitrary match-ups?

traffic ?
a excuses for random discussion about bands we like ?

music is subjective so could you elaborate on what kind of scientific formula you would use for a less arbitrary match-up ?

 

[panic_the_digital]

another vote for floyd, especially if I shut my eyes and plug my ears if someone starts talking about their work after Dark side.

I went for Zep exactly because of that which you don't want to hear of. However, if it weren't for their latter day shit, I would say Floyd in a heartbeat.

 

[Finder]

traffic ?
a excuses for random discussion about bands we like ?

music is subjective so could you elaborate on what kind of scientific formula you would use for a less arbitrary match-up ?

I mean, jazz vs blues makes sense, stooges vs. sex pistols, but Floyd vs Zepp just doesn't make as much sense to me I guess.

 

[ninjadanslarbretabar]

oh im not really trying to make sense
i could have gone with metallica vs bad religion

 

[Finder]

That's just it, the other comparisons generate some discussion, otherwise it's just picking whatever one is your favorite.

 

[GratefulFloyd]

guess....
Pink Floyd to me may be the greatest band of all time, although I enjoy Led Zep I find Pink Floyd's lyrics and sound to more fit my style

 

[ninjadanslarbretabar]

so pink floyd vs grateful dead would have being better ?

 

[GratefulFloyd]

For me yes...... shit that would be an epic battle in my mind trying to decide between the 2. Eitehr way, to me, they are both better than Zep

 

[Psychlone Jack]

Zeppelin all the way.

 

[Finder]

so pink floyd vs grateful dead would have being better ?

I guess. Some other psychedelic band, perhaps. Just ignore me. :D