Is It OK For Me To Have Sex With My Sister? SERIOUS QUESTION

[DavidWhy]

probably better post this on sex, love and relationships

 

[tackyspiral]

i suppose
watch the movie cruel intentions
but for one.... as you said your not blood related
also.... its not like you grew up in the same household and were raised as bro and sis because one of you was adopted or your mom and her dad married while you guys were really little or something

its prob ok lol

 

[DavidWhy]

I will just have to convince my brother, but he will most likely be resigned to it by now as I generally sleep with most girls I meet or work with or go to uni with or just anything really. It's like my version of have a handshake. It just last almost three times as long.

 

[DavidWhy]

I Want To Have Sex With My Sister - Genuine Dilemma - Please Help.

Not really, you fucking sick perverts but it caught your eye didn't it. It is a weird situation though.

Myself and brother have different dads, my bro was born when I was 15. I am 32 now so he is 17. Recently a girl phoned up my mum's house whilst I was visiting and I answered. She explained she was looking for my mum. I asked her why and she said, "Because her son might be my brother". Obviously I thought she meant me, then it transpired that she meant my brother J. He wasn't home so we chatted and all agreed that their dad is a dickhead etc and she seems a really lovely lass. She is 21 and she has a 26 year old sister.

Anyway, I said to her I would Email her a load of photos of her/my brother and when he got home we would speak to him about. I sent the photos, she sent some back... She is a fucking hotty!!!! She is a babe all the way from babesville.

She told she knew she had a little brother and she has been trying to trace him for 6 years, her sister also. My brother spoke to them today and he is really excited about it all, but because me and him grew up close, and his dad wasn't there, I was his male role model, so we just think of each other as full brothers. He said to today that he wants me to be a part of this too and when he goes to meet them, will I come with him.

Damn right I will... One of them is nice looking, the other one, who I have been speaking to most when she phoned and stuff, is just my flavour.... Is it weird if I start dating my brother's sister? Cause I am pretty sure I can seduce her, but I know it will have be a really nice, respectful relationship. I couldn't be a dog to her. But I am about ready to settle down now and I think I might have a crack at this and see if she could be the one.

But what do you think of it? Is it weird? We have never met, we aren't related by blood. It's acceptable isn't it? I think my brother will eventually be OK with if I promise to settle down and be nice to her: he is sort of resigned to me having sex with everyone else. My family and friends know what I am like so he wouldn't have asked me to come if he thought I wouldn't at least attempt to get her into bed at some point. As long as I treat her well, which I will, I am sure he will put in a good word for me.

So now all I need is the approval of my drug addled peers on Bluelight. If I can get the seal of approval from a group of mind blown LSD casualties, Meth Chefs and intravenous Drug users I am home free.

 

[DeathDomokun]

We're sick perverts for reading what you said?

You are a fool.

 

[MrGrunge]

Well, I'm no IV user or LSD casualty, but I am drunk and smoking on some decent herb so I'm probably not the particular voice of reason you're looking for, but...

I'd say go for it. It's an interesting situation for sure, but it doesn't seem to trigger my 'taboo' sensors that much (again - drunk), so do what you gotta do. Of course, you might want to talk to your brother about it if things start getting serious with the girl...but if they don't, have your fun and move on.

 

[DavidWhy]

We're sick perverts for reading what you said? you are a fool.

What is wrong with it? We have never met and we are not related by blood. I am not biologically linked to her than I am to you, so why do find it so offensive? I don't mind your reaction, but at least back it up with something vaguely resembling a coherent argument. Just insulting someone to make a point means you lose by default.

 

[DavidWhy]

Well, I'm no IV user or LSD casualty, but I am drunk and smoking on some decent herb so I'm probably not the particular voice of reason you're looking for, but...

No, that was just a joke, I seem to get along well with people on here and irt is by far one of the less snooty drug sites. I like it.

I'd say go for it. It's an interesting situation for sure, but it doesn't seem to trigger my 'taboo' sensors that much (again - drunk), so do what you gotta do. Of course, you might want to talk to your brother about it if things start getting serious with the girl...but if they don't, have your fun and move on.

Cool. Yeah, if I did anything with her I would treat her with the utmost respect cause she is my brother's half sister, I am getting to settling down age now so I am going to try and make her my number 1, stay at home girl. I mean, this is all providing she doesn't decide I am a sick fuck and kick me in the nuts! I think I have judged her adequately though and I am sure I can close the deal. I will take it slow though so they can have their time.

 

[Jean-Paul]

i find this deeply odd on several different levels.

 

[DavidWhy]

i find this deeply odd on several different levels.

Name 3 levels on which this is odd. I challenge you to a reasoned debate on why this is in anyway odd.

 

[Jean-Paul]

i'm not sure about reasoned debate, but
1. you haven't met her and you have this all really planned out like a sure thing
2. it's your brother's sister
3. if she has never met any of you why what would be the valuable 'word' for him to put in for you

that's pretty much it. i mean you aren't blood related, so it isn't really 'wrong.' it just stuck me as odd.

 

[llama112]

Okay, just to clarify. Your brother J has two parents. His dad (previously) had a daughter with another woman. Then J's dad had a kid (J) with your mom. Your mom already had a kid (you). So J's parents - his dad is blood related to this girl and his mom is blood related to you?

 

[roundnround]

its not incest but if they are building a new family relationship you dont need to muddy the water... good or bad let it be his sister and nothing else

 

[DavidWhy]

1. you haven't met her and this you have this all really planned out like a sure thing

I have seen a photo of her and she is really attractive, but I have only spoken to her for 25 minutes. It wouldn't be funny if I said, "You have a sister who I have virtually nothing about sleeping with her crossed my mind but frankly she could have all manner character flaws, or smell, so I can't accurately judge until the relationship between you both progresses. That would be pretty fucking boring wouln't it compared to constantly tormenting him that I am going to lay his new found sibling.

2. it's your brother's sister

Well that is why I asked if it was weird in the first place. You don't get one over on me for that. It was my point to begin with.

3. if she has never met any of you why what would be the valuable 'word' for him to put in for you

Just generally say how lucky he was to grow up with a brother like me. Gee Wizz, he is such a wonderful guy. That is the good word

that's pretty much it. i mean you aren't blood related, so it isn't really 'wrong.' it just stuck me as odd.

Well you sir are a prude, it is not wrong and many literary figures throughout the ages have married much closer kin than I to this one who I share not on single genetic bond. I think you are shocked that I would be so presumptuous that I can claim that I am able to seduce and sleep with this woman when I know whether or not she is going to prove a hard nut to crack. But believe this dear friend, when mere mortals sleep, my brain is perfecting it's pussy getting getting mechanism. I literally am a total Gal-ist. I can pull a bird like most people can drink a drink. I am fucking good at it.

 

[DavidWhy]

Okay, just to clarify. Your brother J has two parents. His dad (previously) had a daughter with another woman. Then J's dad had a kid (J) with your mom. Your mom already had a kid (you). So J's parents - his dad is blood related to this girl and his mom is blood related to you?

That is correct. Me and J share a mum, different dads.

J and New Girl share a dad. Different mums

Me and New Girl share nothing except a simmering sexual tension that boils and bubbles beneath the emails and text messages we have sent.

its not incest but if they are building a new family relationship you dont need to muddy the water... good or bad let it be his sister and nothing else

Yeah, of course this is all sort of tongue in cheek. I wouldn't try and spoil what could be something really lovely for them. I am going to take it slowly. J has asked me specifically to be a part of it too. He told me that because I am such a big part of his life and not at all just like a half brother he wants me to be close to them too.

 

[bunnymunro]

David, it may be appropriate to confirm with your brother that "being a part of it" includes your satisfaction of your base carnal desires inside an important but thus far denied to him newly acquired sibling. He may actually have a need for family that goes beyond a cum receptacle for an older brother who, more than likely by benefit of age and experience, has probably spoiled any new and unique events in his life. If he bought a new car, would you christen it for him? If the answer is yes, then you are a total arse. Let him enjoy something in life that does not need to become sullied with your penis. I am guessing that he lacks stuff that you haven't had a hand in. So, I believe you should let the young man find his way and enjoy what comes along without your sexual intentions having anything to do with it. It seems to me that you want to try and detract from his happiness. This is the polite version, my previous response was deleted

 

[MrGrunge]

David, it may be appropriate to confirm with your brother that "being a part of it" includes your satisfaction of your base carnal desires inside an important but thus far denied to him newly acquired sibling. He may actually have a need for family that goes beyond a cum receptacle for an older brother who, more than likely by benefit of age and experience, has probably spoiled any new and unique events in his life. If he bought a new car, would you christen it for him? If the answer is yes, then you are a total arse. Let him enjoy something in life that does not need to become sullied with your penis. I am guessing that he lacks stuff that you haven't had a hand in. So, I believe you should let the young man find his way and enjoy what comes along without your sexual intentions having anything to do with it. It seems to me that you want to try and detract from his happiness. This is the polite version, my previous response was deleted

After sobering up a bit and re-reading this thread I'm gonna have to retract my previous post and concur with bunnymunro. Some things are better better left unsullied by penis.

 

[Pagey]

In the offchance that this is actually a legitimate question and not a troll as it appears to be, I'm going to say no. a) That's just weird and sounds really incestuous even if you're not blood-related and b)That would be horrible for your brother.

P.S. Would be more helpful in the future if you could use accurate titles rather than something to just catch people's attention.

 

[footscrazy]

Well you sir are a prude, it is not wrong and many literary figures throughout the ages have married much closer kin than I to this one who I share not on single genetic bond

/thread? It seems like you've decided the answer to your question and aren't interested in hearing anything to the contrary.

 

[Pagey]

^Good point, OP I'm not sure you're really asking a question, just looking for confirmation, and I can see this getting quickly out of hand. Gonna close the thread, PM me if you want it re-opened.