High suicide rate of veterinarians blamed on easy access to drugs

fruitfly

Bluelight Crew
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Messages
8,071
VETS are nearly four times as likely to commit suicide as other members of the public, and twice as likely as doctors or dentists, research shows.

Easy access to lethal drugs and familiarity with animal euthanasia have been blamed for the higher suicide rate. One expert said vets were working within a "culture of death".

The relative lack of support for people working in small, often isolated practices was also highlighted yesterday by support groups, who called for better training among veterinary students to cope with the pressures of the job.

Richard Mellanby, a vet and researcher at Cambridge University's pathology department, found that male vets in England and Wales had a suicide rate of 3.6 times the national average between 1979 and 1990, and 3.7 between 1991 and 2000.

Although similar data has not been analysed in Scotland, the researchers said they expected a similar picture.

Mr Mellanby hopes the results, published in the Veterinary Record, the British Veterinary Association's journal, will act as a wake-up call for the profession to provide urgent help.

He said: "It would be good if it led to an increased recognition of the problems within the profession and helped reduce the stigmatisation of mental health problems and made it easier for people to get help. There also needs to be greater research so the profession can see what problems it needs to address."

Austin Kirwin, chair of the Veterinary Help Line, which gives advice and support to as many as 200 vets a year, said problems ranged from financial hardship to family breakdowns, career issues, mental health problems and addictions.

But he said several factors distinguished vets from other professionals working in stressful environments, including their familiarity with the process of euthanasia and the means to commit suicide.

"The stresses involved in working in an environment where you are dealing day-to-day with euthanasia and advising clients who are having their own animals put down are very great," he said.

"It was found that veterinary surgeons are working within a culture of death.

"If an animal is in a hopeless situation, it is destroyed, so when a vet is depressed and feels their situation is hopeless, they are more likely to commit suicide."

The culture shock of emerging from university and going to work in a small practice – unlike doctors who go to work within the NHS with thousands of others – exacerbated the problem, Mr Kirwin said.

"Vets usually find themselves working in a small practice, possibly on their own with one or two other support staff."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
High suicide rate of vets blamed on easy access to drugs
The Herald (UK)
October 6, 2005


Link
 
Thats pretty sad. I'd often thought about that as I have a friend whos a vet. After all the pressure in putting our cat down, I can't imagine doing this everyday.
 
I had always wondered if vets are immune to these types of feelings since they put down animals all the time, I guess they are not.

I wouldn't blame that on easy access to drugs though, it's more of a combination of being depressed from inability to help so many animals which they surely love (or know they can help them but owners refuse to pay $$$ and take the cheaper route) AND availability of some lethal drugs.

:(
 
i for one couldnt bear to work as a vet...i love animals...not particularly dogs, cuz i had half my face, literally ripped off and open from a german shepard...but i love cats....and weve had to put to sleep 1 of ours cuz we couldnt bear to give him shots daily and the medical costs, he was a diabetic cat...

i can see tho...i mean the animal is in a hopeless situation and theres 1 peaceful way out.....the vets see the same 1 peaceful way out...its sad really but i do feel for them
 
its always been common knowledge that dentists have the highest suicide rates, but this study suggests otherwise. I doubt its access to drugs
 
or know they can help them but owners refuse to pay $$$ and take the cheaper route
I'd say this is a major factor, because major emergency operations can be thousands of dollars, that the owners aren't willing to spend on an animal that can be "replaced" for free at the pound... Sad, but that's how some people look at it!
 
It would be tough being a vet, having to do all kinds of things to animals...listen to their cries.

I think a lot of people neglect their animals too much, or keep them locked up too much. It would be painful to see all these sick animals come in all the time because their owners suck.
 
My wife was a vet. nurse when I first met her and her opinion is that it's not so much to do with animal euthanasia, but others aspects. Vets become vets because they want to do medicine, but don't want to have to deal with people. Little do they realize that working in a small vet. practice means that they're coming into contact with people every day, some of whom get very aggressive because their animal needs treatment, but they can't afford (or will not pay for) treatment.

I've got to admit that just about all the vets I knew where my wife used to work had some sort of chemical dependance; with most it was alcohol, but others were fond of benzos, barbiturates, opiates etc., (one South African vet was the first one to convince me that ketamine was a worthwile experience!). As we all know, once you develop a chemical dependance it can really fuck with your emotions etc.

Despite all the above doom & gloom, the vets I knew there were some of the friendliest, kind hearted professional people I've ever met. Not one had the sort of superiority complex that you can generally find in other professions
 
It would be interesting if someone could find the depression rates of doctors in similiar areas.

I wonder if they are twice as likely as vets to be depressed.
 
i would have thought as a part of the medical training that vet's are taught how to deal with death and the psychological aspects of the job?

aren't doctors are taught on how to deal with dead bodies, gore and other such aspects?
 
bowdenta said:
its always been common knowledge that dentists have the highest suicide rates, but this study suggests otherwise. I doubt its access to drugs

Studies don't seem to confirm that popular notion, but then again they weren't very extensive, so definitely take the ranking with a grain of salt:

1. Food batchmakers (241)
2. Physicians (222)
3. Health aides (excluding nursing) (221)
4. Lathe and turning machine operators (199)
5. Biological, life and medical scientists (188 )
6. Social scientists and urban planners (171)
7. Dentists (165)
8. Lawyers and Judges (140)
9-10. Guards/sales occupations were tied at 139
11. Tool and die makers (126)
12. Police, public servants (118 )

http://www.straightdope.com/mailbag/msuicide.html

--- G.
 
My "suicide index number" seems to be surprisingly high (188 ). And I can get easily only ethanol and ether at my work...
 
i've been in the animal care profession for years, but i've never worked inside a vet's office precisely because i know i can't handle the gore of just-runover pets and dog-fight victims. this article is fascinating to me.
 
^^
Its in the article when you follow the link from Morrison's Laments post.

Biological, life and medical scientists (188 )
 
Top