In regards to ECT, I was fed the typical US medical "consensus" in medical school. I have not only seen the procedure carried out, I have provided anesthetsia /life-support for 6 procedures. The patients who were treated were all female, with a long history of severe psychiatric disorders. These women were truly sick; suffering from the worst cases of major depression I have seen. This type of depression is not your" run of the mill" housewife/moody teenagers; these individuals are bed ridden, crippled and effectively zero-function patients.
Most had some related psychosis, some more than others. One woman, was lucid prior to the procedure, exhibiting no psychosis, but was suffering from 'organic' major depression. While very lucid, apparently rather intelligent (and surprisingly attractive,; she was in her mid 30s, but looked younger), she was littered with the scars of the numerous attempts to end her life (most disturbingly, a scar on the throat; which I found out later was a technically 'successful ' suicide - she was revived from massive hypovolemic shock). She had previously undergone 4 ECT treatments with some transient effect, but willingly and knowingly requested and consented to the procedure. I have no idea what ended up happening to her, but she recovered quickly after treatment, seemingly with little amnesia/cog-deficit.
Other cases were more clear-cut, one female, in complete and total catatonia, underwent the procedure, and after-recovery, was responsive and effectively broken from the catatonic state. How long did this last; I don't know.
The procedure should be a last resort, but may or may not have therapeutic validity. I am honestly unsure, aside from my experience in its ability to break catatonic states, of its value.
A much more disturbing, dangerous, and damaging procedure (having observed the horrors) is rapid opioid detoxification under general anesthesia. This procedure should be banned, and the profiting advocates of this procedure should be prosecuted in a criminal court of law. They know that the procedure is harmful and dangerous, but proceed nonetheless given the high profit margin on these procedures.
To the question, please elaborate on the symptoms and other factors surrounding said MDMA induced depression, and the circumstances of the night in question.
Most had some related psychosis, some more than others. One woman, was lucid prior to the procedure, exhibiting no psychosis, but was suffering from 'organic' major depression. While very lucid, apparently rather intelligent (and surprisingly attractive,; she was in her mid 30s, but looked younger), she was littered with the scars of the numerous attempts to end her life (most disturbingly, a scar on the throat; which I found out later was a technically 'successful ' suicide - she was revived from massive hypovolemic shock). She had previously undergone 4 ECT treatments with some transient effect, but willingly and knowingly requested and consented to the procedure. I have no idea what ended up happening to her, but she recovered quickly after treatment, seemingly with little amnesia/cog-deficit.
Other cases were more clear-cut, one female, in complete and total catatonia, underwent the procedure, and after-recovery, was responsive and effectively broken from the catatonic state. How long did this last; I don't know.
The procedure should be a last resort, but may or may not have therapeutic validity. I am honestly unsure, aside from my experience in its ability to break catatonic states, of its value.
A much more disturbing, dangerous, and damaging procedure (having observed the horrors) is rapid opioid detoxification under general anesthesia. This procedure should be banned, and the profiting advocates of this procedure should be prosecuted in a criminal court of law. They know that the procedure is harmful and dangerous, but proceed nonetheless given the high profit margin on these procedures.
To the question, please elaborate on the symptoms and other factors surrounding said MDMA induced depression, and the circumstances of the night in question.