ketadvocate
Greenlighter
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2013
- Messages
- 7
(I should have made it more clear in my earlier post that I am talking only about treatment resistant depression: depression that has persisted for a very long time and has not responded to other treatments.)
I got my info from a combination of sources, motivated by my personal experience. After 30+ years of extreme depression, I had lost nearly everything important to me and was virtually disabled. I volunteered for a ketamine study at the National Institutes of Health, and a single infusion completely relieved all of my symptoms within a few hours. It is the most important thing that has ever happened to me, so for the past year I've been studying the research, talking to doctors and scientists, getting additional treatment, and comparing notes with other people like me. My comments above are based on face-to-face conversations at NIH with some of the leading ketamine researchers (Dr. Zarate, et al); reading every word of every published ketamine research paper I have found; attending conferences and watching webinars of all the major researchers (Drs. Murrough, Chrystal, Duman, Sanacora, et al); talking to experienced ketamine doctors (Dr. Brooks, Dr. Sajben, et al) who have decades of experience with the drug itself and over the past few years have treated hundreds of depression patients with this new protocol; carefully monitoring my own personal response to various ketamine doses and ROAs; and constant cross-talk with many other people like me who have actual ketamine experience (medical treatment, not recreational use).
So that's why I think what I think about ROA. I've absorbed a lot of info, but do not feel comfortable attempting to explain the details about WHY the antidepressant effect are so dependent on ROA and rate. Some of the deeper details are beyond me, anyway, because they require an understanding of neurology, neuropharmacology, and other knowledge I lack. My personal experience certainly shapes my view, but I have confidence in my assertion about ROA+rate because I've also developed relationships with expert doctors and expert patients and I've grown to trust them. Most of that trust comes from many long talks with practicing doctors -- not researchers -- who are using ketamine to heal real live patients, including a veteran anesthesiologist with 40 years of ketamine experience. And many more, even longer talks with people like me who were suffering acute misery, felt dramatic relief from a single infusion in a clinical trial, and have since received ongoing clinical treatment via a variety of ROAs. Some of us have achieved partial relief from intranasal, but we all agree the relief from IV was vastly superior.
In discussing ROA with the people above, many of them have pointed out that ketamine has been around for 50+ years and is very widely used, and if any old ROA worked on depression it would have been noticed decades earlier. In the 90s some doctors began using it off-label to treat CRPS/RPS and other extreme physical pain ailments. Through trial and error, they found that sub anesthetic IV doses really helped. Those patients often suffer from depression, too, and doctors noticed that some of them felt happier when their pain was relieved. It's not surprising they were depressed given their extreme pain, and it's not surprising they felt happier afterward. But someone eventually made the leap to ask if they were happier solely due to their pain relief, or if maybe the ketamine helped the depression independently. The earliest scholarly studies were done at Yale circa 2000.
Regarding your doctor, I agree with Foreigner. She sounds very under-informed to me. The idea of dosing orally for depression and her comment about it "building up" in your system make me really question her level of knowledge. I commend her for being willing to consider it for off-label depression use, but compared to all the people I listed above, she is far off in left field. I'd hate to see either of you give up on ketamine treatment or discourage others from considering it, if you have a non-response to oral. Perhaps you could encourage her to speak to one of the experienced ketamine doctors listed on the Ketamine Advocacy Network website?
In case it's useful, here's a list of doctors who offer ketamine treatment for pain: http://neurotalk.psychcentral.com/thread148368.html. I'm sure some of them are also offering the depression IV protocol, or would be willing to.
Regarding the cost of infusion, there is no consistency in pricing yet. Keep in mind that a doctor who offers IV ketamine has to cover some pretty high costs. I did research to see what it would cost to open a "ketamine clinic" in my state and was astonished at the costs involved. If you are a doctor who wants to use a dissociative anesthetic for an off-label use on a severe mental illness with a high suicide rate, be prepared to pay malpractice premiums in the hundreds of thousands of dollars per year. Your office will need to have at least one dedicated treatment room, outfitted with specialized equipment usually found only in large facilities (infusion pumps, treatment chairs, monitoring equipment, etc.), nursing and admin support (maybe), etc. I'm not going to defend or condemn anyone's pricing here, but I can say that the $900 you were quoted is at the extreme top end of the scale. You might find someone cheaper, but if you have to travel to see them and pay for a hotel, the overall cost might be no better. Arctica, feel free to PM me if you want to discuss details about my infusion doctor.
I got my info from a combination of sources, motivated by my personal experience. After 30+ years of extreme depression, I had lost nearly everything important to me and was virtually disabled. I volunteered for a ketamine study at the National Institutes of Health, and a single infusion completely relieved all of my symptoms within a few hours. It is the most important thing that has ever happened to me, so for the past year I've been studying the research, talking to doctors and scientists, getting additional treatment, and comparing notes with other people like me. My comments above are based on face-to-face conversations at NIH with some of the leading ketamine researchers (Dr. Zarate, et al); reading every word of every published ketamine research paper I have found; attending conferences and watching webinars of all the major researchers (Drs. Murrough, Chrystal, Duman, Sanacora, et al); talking to experienced ketamine doctors (Dr. Brooks, Dr. Sajben, et al) who have decades of experience with the drug itself and over the past few years have treated hundreds of depression patients with this new protocol; carefully monitoring my own personal response to various ketamine doses and ROAs; and constant cross-talk with many other people like me who have actual ketamine experience (medical treatment, not recreational use).
So that's why I think what I think about ROA. I've absorbed a lot of info, but do not feel comfortable attempting to explain the details about WHY the antidepressant effect are so dependent on ROA and rate. Some of the deeper details are beyond me, anyway, because they require an understanding of neurology, neuropharmacology, and other knowledge I lack. My personal experience certainly shapes my view, but I have confidence in my assertion about ROA+rate because I've also developed relationships with expert doctors and expert patients and I've grown to trust them. Most of that trust comes from many long talks with practicing doctors -- not researchers -- who are using ketamine to heal real live patients, including a veteran anesthesiologist with 40 years of ketamine experience. And many more, even longer talks with people like me who were suffering acute misery, felt dramatic relief from a single infusion in a clinical trial, and have since received ongoing clinical treatment via a variety of ROAs. Some of us have achieved partial relief from intranasal, but we all agree the relief from IV was vastly superior.
In discussing ROA with the people above, many of them have pointed out that ketamine has been around for 50+ years and is very widely used, and if any old ROA worked on depression it would have been noticed decades earlier. In the 90s some doctors began using it off-label to treat CRPS/RPS and other extreme physical pain ailments. Through trial and error, they found that sub anesthetic IV doses really helped. Those patients often suffer from depression, too, and doctors noticed that some of them felt happier when their pain was relieved. It's not surprising they were depressed given their extreme pain, and it's not surprising they felt happier afterward. But someone eventually made the leap to ask if they were happier solely due to their pain relief, or if maybe the ketamine helped the depression independently. The earliest scholarly studies were done at Yale circa 2000.
Regarding your doctor, I agree with Foreigner. She sounds very under-informed to me. The idea of dosing orally for depression and her comment about it "building up" in your system make me really question her level of knowledge. I commend her for being willing to consider it for off-label depression use, but compared to all the people I listed above, she is far off in left field. I'd hate to see either of you give up on ketamine treatment or discourage others from considering it, if you have a non-response to oral. Perhaps you could encourage her to speak to one of the experienced ketamine doctors listed on the Ketamine Advocacy Network website?
In case it's useful, here's a list of doctors who offer ketamine treatment for pain: http://neurotalk.psychcentral.com/thread148368.html. I'm sure some of them are also offering the depression IV protocol, or would be willing to.
Regarding the cost of infusion, there is no consistency in pricing yet. Keep in mind that a doctor who offers IV ketamine has to cover some pretty high costs. I did research to see what it would cost to open a "ketamine clinic" in my state and was astonished at the costs involved. If you are a doctor who wants to use a dissociative anesthetic for an off-label use on a severe mental illness with a high suicide rate, be prepared to pay malpractice premiums in the hundreds of thousands of dollars per year. Your office will need to have at least one dedicated treatment room, outfitted with specialized equipment usually found only in large facilities (infusion pumps, treatment chairs, monitoring equipment, etc.), nursing and admin support (maybe), etc. I'm not going to defend or condemn anyone's pricing here, but I can say that the $900 you were quoted is at the extreme top end of the scale. You might find someone cheaper, but if you have to travel to see them and pay for a hotel, the overall cost might be no better. Arctica, feel free to PM me if you want to discuss details about my infusion doctor.