In a Silent Way - Miles Davis
Of course my favorite album 'of all the time' switches 'all of the time'%)
but really, NOTHING in the history of recorded sound has approached what Miles Davis did on this album. I have listened to it hundreds and hundreds of times and I will always find something new (really this is an amazing characteristic of jazz in general, in more general you could say it is a characteristic of all music)
BUT, 'In a Silent Way' is somewhere off of the map. And of course it was all improvised, on the spot, apparently recorded in one day. You can almost see them, three keyboardists, drummer and Miles, down on 30th Street, in that studio. It must have been dimly lit. I wonder what time it was. I would hurt the defenseless to see a video of the session. The guitar which wanders in and around, subtly directing, with the keys in easy competition behind it. And then Miles comes in with that trumpet solo, which is IMO the best solo in recorded music, and that takes everything over. You can feel the other musicians noticing that something special is happening there, as they try fail and gloriously succeed in providing the accompaniment.
IT IS Jazz. It is pure jazz because it is pure music, written by the instantaneous mood and moment, people locked together in the goal of simply existing. That is jazz. But traditional jazz has all of it's idioms and it's lexicon of feeling and expression. 'In a Silent Way' is jazz music, instant music, broken free from any of the previous conventions that held and still hold what jazz expression is and should be.
That is the definition of it. But on the emotional side, 'In a Silent Way' goes somewhere that is both never reached and constantly known. What I mean by that broad and seemingly crapoala statement is that the album finds a piece of expression that although it is with us all of the time, never gets articulated. Honestly I believe that there are infinitely many of these expressions. That is the wonder of Jazz.
Apologies if this is all too cerebral. It's a cerebral album. But more than that, in the way of the best way of the cerebral, it is just as good on the surface as it is further and further below. Throw into the mix that it was done by one of the 20th century's best musicians, at his creative peak, in a time of creative explosion and uncertainty, brimmed and edging with the changing of every convention. And that is why I pick this album as the best of all time.
Edit: Really it is Track 1: 'Shhh- Peaceful', that I am talking about.