Knows: Are you a follower of AA? Have you been in one of their treatment programs? Let me ask how old you are and what is your level of education. Why do you believe it's not possible to control drug use, even after being out of control? Why can't somebody be or formerly be addicted and out of control but later learn to control it and enjoy it? Isn't reasonable that somebody could learn to control it from their experience of overdoing it? How carefully did you read Crowley's book?
I don't know much about AA other than they preach total abstinence and don't seem to believe recreational use is possible. They are also fond of words like "clean," and "addict." They believe everyone is helpless, has no will power, and must rely on outside help including a "higher power." They are very preachy. I don't care for their philosophy, but it does help certain kinds of people, especially drunks.
And yes, I've read Crowley's Diary of a Drug Fiend. The characters didnt know what they were getting themselves into and went overboard. They didn't use their "Will" to keep themselves disciplined. They lost control over themselves and became slaves to their addiction. But in the end, they quit, and Crowley suggested that one could overcome addiction and still use drugs just when they wanted to and not lose control over themselves and their will in the process. You summarized it just like that.
Crowley wrote for a very specific audience - smart and curious people who he was encouraging to think for themselves and develop will power and self-reliance. He encouraged people to take charge of their own lives and to try to realize their dreams. He was also fond of theatrics and pageantry
I agree with Crowley on that it i possible to keep control, even while physically dependent. By control, I mean keep the amount under control and not ruin your life while taking the drug. Yes, I realize physical dependence can happen quickly. I don't think physical depedence is as big a deal as people make it out to be. You can be in control and also be physically dependent. You can control the amount you take, you can decide if you want to quit, you can control how you quit, whether its sudden or a taper. Quitting relatively painlessly is a matter of tapering over several weeks. It takes willpower, something AA doesn't seem to believe in - maybe because they will lose customers or followers or whatever.
Why do you think one cannot be both addicted to something yet also able to enjoy it? I have 3 examples, and each one proves that is wrong. I used to be addicted to alcohol. I drank heavily every day for a year while in grad school. I would litteraly start shaking, sweating, and have extreme anxiety by mid-day if I didn't have a drink. I tapered off, and now, I only drink 1 or 2 drinks a month and get drunk once a year. That was 7 years ago.
I'm currently addicted to 2 substances that I also enjoy. I have been taking both every day for years. One of them is caffeine. Did you know that one can become physically dependent on coffee? I am a caffeine addict and it is not pretty. I MUST drink a caffienated beverage each day that contains at least 200 milligrams of caffeine or I get some very nasty withdrawal symptoms: migraine, extreme vomiting, chills, extreme lack of energy - I just lie in bed for a few days until it wears off, constipation, depression, extreme sleepiness. It lasts 3 or 4 days when I have quit caffeine cold turkey. I've learned to taper when I need to quit. I'm an addict, but at the same time, I enjoy coffee after years of daily use.
It might sound insane to you and to the abstinence world of AA, but Crowley's suggestion works for some people. I've taken opiates on weekends only for more than a decade. Then I had steady access to cheap fentanyl. After my year or so run with daily fentanyl, my supply was going to run out, and I didn't want to spend more than I could afford to keep doing it. I did a long slow taper and quit everything for around 6 months. I was physically dependent, but I was able to quit.
Because I find that daily use of opiates enhances life, and I had access to affordable heroin, I decided to take up heroin and decided to do it every day. That was more than a year ago. I did iv heroin sometimes but was never really into the rush. I've also injected speedballs and really enjoyed that rush. I switched to morphine taken orally. Morning and afternoon are maintenance doses. Evening is recreational. I use the same amount every day. I still enjoy it. I've had some roughj patches learning to do it right, but I have not lost control over myself. I'm quitting in about 2 months before I have to travel overseas. Yes, I realize I'm physically addicted, but after a slow taper, I will no longer be addicted. I have the self discipline to do a taper on my own without having to be locked in some substance "abuse" treatment center. In that sense, I have total control over it. Cold turkey is masochistic. After my travels, I plan to start it up again. I have self-discipline not only when it comes to drugs but in other areas of life as well. I do double marathon length runs, 100+ mile bike rides, mountain climb. I have a PhD in Neuroscience and work in my field.
So, yes, I agree with Crowley. I think he took heroin because he chose to and he enjoyed it. That's why I take it. I think the AA mindset is propaganda designed to help certain kinds of people. Certain kinds of people need slogans and black and white interpretations of life and strict rules set in stone. Everybody is different. Not everybody reacts to addictive substances the same way.
If you are still skeptical, millions of people are prescribed pain management medication that contains opiates every day and don't lose control. If they did, they would all be supplementing their doses with whatever they can buy on the street.
Willow: yes, it is risky to take something for pleasure that you are addicted to. I'm addicted to 2 things: caffeine and morphine. After years of daily use, I still enjoy them both very much. I don't recommend this lifestyle for most mortals. Why can some people be addicted yet have completely normal lives while others crash and burn? Knowledge about the drug, self-discipline (as in being able to train and run 50 miles without rest, having a zen meditation training, etc)?