I guess the Shulgin's scale is about levels of depth in a drug experience, specially suited for complex experiences as psychedelics, but even if the scale determine some objective "marks" those marks are subjectively felt, so for someone 40mg of 4-ho-mipt could be a +++ and for other person a ++++ and actually be like that, for physiological reasons, set, setting.... etc.
I actually don't remember the entire Shulgin's experiences but I guess it would be pretty odd if he only rated mdma with a ++++ taking account what DMT, 5-meo-DMT or other psychedelics can do...
I talked about 4-ho-mipt cause I consider it a very spiritual substance,I find people put too much emphasis on potency. I always found LSD to be potent, but it lacks the kind of spiritual depth delivered by MDMA (when its pure and not being abused). LSD puts you in touch with some level of consciousness in the earth, the sky, the water and so on - but i think as a species our most profound experience is the force generated between people. It is the experience of coming to peace with humanity, to see the unique beauty in each person and have concern for all. For me it was this that put MDMA in a class of its own. There are drugs with more intense visuals and physical sensations but none of them felt truly transcendental. Of course the more you use the more it becomes like a mere better version of speed (albeit much better). Pretty much every other psychedelic iv ever tried has only had a superficial quality re spiritual value.
a ++++ is total control of the universe you have super powers like telekensis and become god.
He never had a plus four on mdma.
He only ever had about two to three
In my case my breakthrough on DMT was trascendental, I just couldn't believe what had happent, I was saying: "oohh fuck,,, oh fuck, incredible, I don't believe it!" for more than 15 minutes straight, and I couldn't really understand what happent, I was frightened, full of awe, full of gratitude to be here again, with my most deep thoughts solidly anchored but at the same time re-arranged, like a new dimension of being myself.Yes people often forget a ++++ is an experience most will only have once maybe 2-3x if they are lucky. Many trip their whole lives and never get a ++++. It’s the type of experience that changes someone fundamentally for the rest of their life, all preconceived notions are erased. It’s not just a really strong trip like many want to equate a plus4 as.. That’s a +++.
+ = threshold/light trip
++ = medium/solid experience
+++ = very strong experience, fully immersed, in the case of DMT this is your breakthrough
++++ = transcendental, without explanation
-GC